Pretty Boy is an unabashedly sharp cheese with a propensity for the gilded and grandiose. Aged to perfection, this charming sharp cheddar is opulent with copious amounts of character as expected from a Wisconsin-made fella. Have a hunk with a cured salami and mustard, or he'll lend a steadfast
4.7
340 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Delicious
We love your cheese!! I got redirected and ordered by mistake from another shop. I won't make that mistake again.
A
Anonymous · July 30, 2026
Its ok
Pamela · December 12, 2025
Finally a sharp cheddar that has intense flavor. Grocery brands are hardly sharp at all. Yummy!