This is the product description text that will appear here.
Quantity
1
One time purchase
$11.75
Subscribe & save
Save 10%
$10.58$11.75
Delivers every month
REMEMBER--UNOPENED just in your refrigerator, our aged cheddars will last FOREVER and continue to get better in the years to come so it's cheaper to stock up! GLUTEN-FREE | EXTREMELY KETO-FRIENDLY!
Our 2 best seller! Aged for 8 years, this smooth and creamy cheddar melts away in your mouth like butter and packs a powerful, super-sharp pun
4.9
747 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
This cheese ruined me for anything in the grocery store marked 'sharp'. If you want a truly sharp cheddar cheese for every day use, this is the one you want. It's tangy and creamy and melts well with dishes.
Betti · September 30, 2026
Love this cheese, had the eight year-old sharp cheddar today so creamy but yet still on the dry side, but in a good way. We enjoyed the garlic cheese as well. Definitely be ordering more in the future.
A
Annette · September 25, 2026
Are you kitten me?
“This is hands-down the most excellent sharp cheese ever. Wisconsin cheese can’t be beat! If I don’t have this in the fridge, I just stop cooking. Seriously—it’s that good. Worth every penny, honey!”