Classic Cake Eyeliner transforms your eyes in seconds! This versatile product can take you from a delicately defined lash line to intense smolder and color with just a few strokes. Use wet or dry. Best applied with our #1 Eyeliner brush.
3.5
4 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
I seem to be allergic to something in this color. Eyeshot red and gooey.
S
Sharon · June 26, 2026
very nice but still bleeds even with the eyelid foundation
A
Anonymous · December 11, 2025
Smudge and fallout :(
Jury's still out -- I've used this eyeliner a few times so far and I really like the color, but it's smudging and causing some fallout. I'm going to try it one more time before I decide to return because I really want to love it.