It started as a Halloween limited edition. You wouldn't let it go.
Two years ago our community voted Franken Butter into existence — a cookie dough peanut butter loaded with chocolate sandwich cookies, peanut butter cups, and chocolate-coated peanut butter candies. We made it for one spooky season. You made it permanent.
That's the
4.7
291 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
I have been using this in my picky kiddos lunch box all October. He is digging it! Willing to dip things he usually leaves untouched ;).
Jantonia · October 27, 2026
Not what I expected.
jennifer · 2 days ago
Great mixed up and used soo many ways, put some in dish, warm in micro and put over ice cream!!