The Original Caramel

Name: Butterfly Bakery of Vermont The Original Caramel - The Original Caramel
Brand: Butterfly Bakery of Vermont
SKU: 43742952948017
Price: 7.59 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5 (7 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$7.59

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

Our velvety goat's milk caramel sauces (Cajeta) combine creamy caramel richness with the subtle tang of goat's milk to create an utterly unique, not-too-sweet dessert sauce perfectly paired with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses. Fat Toad Farm Caramel Sauces have a 18 month shelf life and should be refrigerated after opening.
The slow cooking

5.0

12 ratings

Love that this bakery supports small Vermont farms!

Hillary · September 14, 2026

delicious

robert · October 3, 2026

Love it, so delicious, i put it on my French toast, scoop up a spoon n eat it by itself

Martha · June 29, 2026

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

4.9 (508)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Vanilla Bean Caramel

(7)

$7.59

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cinnamon Caramel

(3)

$7.59

Harmacy Hot Sauce Co.

4.9

(1.1K)

Harmacy Hot Sauce Co. 'Buffalo Soldier' sauce jar with pineapple, lime, and spices on a white background

Jar of Harmacy Hot Sauce Co. 'Smoke Signal' pepper sauce with apricot slices and a bottle of maple syrup on a white background.

Hot sauce jar with 'Harmacy Hot Sauce Co.' label surrounded by citrus fruits and herbs on a white background

Harmacy Hot Sauce Brimstone Pepper Sauce jar with peppers and sauce on a white background

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard

(8)

$11.00

Queen Majesty Jalapeño, Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce, 5 oz - All Natural, Vegan, Kosher, Gluten Free, non GMO, No Sugar, Made in the USA, Award Winning

8% off

Fresh Kart USA

Queen Majesty Jalapeño, Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce, 5 oz - All Natural, Vegan, Kosher, Gluten Free, non GMO, No Sugar, Made in the USA, Award Winning

$28.44$30.80

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mighty Tasty Granola

(17)

$9.29

Shade Time Artisan Hot Sauce

4.8

(4)

"Bottle of Caribbean Scorch hot sauce with curry spices and chiles"

"Bottle of Smoke hot sauce with smoked Scotch Bonnet peppers"

"Mango Blaze hot sauce bottle with mangoes and habanero peppers"

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Heady Topper Hot Sauce

(7)

$11.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Red Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce

(10)

$11.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Chocolate Peppermint Snaps

(4)

$7.00

California Hot Sauce Solutions

(49)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Vermont Habs Hot Sauce

(5)

$11.00

Bottle of Elderflower Ghost Craft Spirit hot sauce on a wooden surface with peppers and a bottle of rum in the background

27% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce

(5)

$11.00$15.00

Bernal Cutlery

Queen Majesty Jalapeño Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce - 5oz

$10.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

(6)

$5.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Salted Bourbon Caramel

(5)

$7.59

Matty's Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Fat Toad Caramel - Cold Brew Coffee

(1)

$7.50

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce

(12)

$11.00

Indie Indie Bang! Bang!

Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce

$10.95

High Desert Sauce Co

4.9

(3.5K)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Gingersnaps

(6)

$7.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce

(6)

$11.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Raspberry Almond Cookies

(3)

$6.00

Rancho Gordo

(2.5K)

Good Mother Stallard Bean - Rancho Gordo

NewEngland.com Store

Mulled Cider Caramel 8oz

(1)

$16.99

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Peppercorn Porter Hot Sauce

(5)

$11.00

The Kitchen

Queen Majesty Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce, 5oz

$10.00

Fishwife

4.8

(14.3K)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

GusterNola - Miller Mix

(2)

$9.29

Murder Hornet Hot Sauce

4.8

(284)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Mulled Cider Caramel

(1)

$7.59

petit-quartet-caramel-set-original-vanilla-bean-vermont-maple-salted-bourbon

pucciManuli

Petit Quartet Goats Milk Caramel Set

$39.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Gustard - A Guster Mustard

(10)

$11.00

HEATONIST

4.7

(22.8K)

Spice is Peachy Hot Sauce by Korn, 6 oz bottle

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Scape Sauce

(8)

$11.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

(21)

$15.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Rum Chipotle Hot Sauce

(8)

$11.00

Karma Sauce

4.9

(129)

Ghost Island hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Cosmic Dumpling hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Cherry Bomb hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Bad Karma Sauce hot sauce by Karma Sauce Company LLC

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Ooh La La - A Guster Hot Sauce

(3)

$11.00

Precycle

2oz Spicy Dark Chocolate Goat's Milk Caramel

$7.59

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Peanut Maple Vanilla Granola

(3)

$9.29

Olive My Pickle

4.6

(38.5K)

LiveBrine Probiotic Pickle Juice: Classic Kosher Dill

Browns Kitchen

$9.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Sriracha Mustard

(4)

$11.00

50% off

Hot Graham Sauce Company LLC

Dies Irae (Day of Wrath) Hot Sauce

$7.50$15.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Vermont Jalapeno Mustard

(3)

$11.00

Vermont's Own Gifts & Goods

Fat Toad Farm Caramel - Butterfly Bakery

$7.59

Clean, crunchy protein

From Biena Snacks, The Only Bean, and Nuts.com.

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

DIY Caramel Apple Kit

$23.49

From pantry to pasta party

Pasta shapes, tinned fish, and capers.

Queen Majesty Hot Sauce - Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce, 5 Fl Oz (2 Pack) - All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free, Sugar Free, Made in the USA, Featured

8% off

Fresh Kart USA

Queen Majesty Hot Sauce - Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce, 5 Fl Oz (2 Pack) - All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free, Sugar Free, Made in the USA, Featured

$43.85$47.90

Game-day dips

Salsas, queso, and party snacks.

8% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Signature Hot Sauce Sampler

(9)

(3)

$7.59

Exclusive deal available

Nola Sauce Bar

Salted Bourbon Goat's Milk Caramel 8oz

(39)

$19.99

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce

(30)

$11.00

Irresistible sweet treats

Cookies, sauces, and sprinkles.

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Barrel Aged Cold Brewed Vanilla Extract

(2)

$20.00

Fat Toad Farm Sweet Duo Original & Salted Bourbon

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Sweet Duo Caramel Gift Box

(1)

$34.99

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Habanero Lime Switchback Craft Beer Hot Sauce

(10)

$11.00

Captain Mowatt's

4.9

(2.9K)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Earl Grey & Orange Snaps

(3)

$7.00

Fat Toad Farm Full Line of Goat's Milk Caramel Sauces

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

The Top Flight

(2)

$120.00

Farmhouse Teas

Caramel Apple Kit | Fat Toad Farm

(2)

$32.00

Snake River Farms

4.6

(15.8K)

raw SRF Black® tomahawk steak |SRF Black®

The Kitchen

Queen Majesty Jalapeño Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce, 5oz

$10.00

27% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Red Ghost Reaper Hot Sauce

(9)

$11.00$15.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Maple Sparkle Sriracha Pride Hot Sauce

(5)

$11.00

The Original Caramel

Highlights

Description

Specifications

Reviews5.0(12)

Delivery & Returns

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

You might also like

Vanilla Bean Caramel

Cinnamon Caramel

Harmacy Hot Sauce Co.

Hard Cider Smoked Onion Mustard

Queen Majesty Jalapeño, Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce, 5 oz - All Natural, Vegan, Kosher, Gluten Free, non GMO, No Sugar, Made in the USA, Award Winning

Mighty Tasty Granola

Shade Time Artisan Hot Sauce

Heady Topper Hot Sauce

Red Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce

Chocolate Peppermint Snaps

California Hot Sauce Solutions

Vermont Habs Hot Sauce

Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce

Queen Majesty Jalapeño Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce - 5oz

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

Salted Bourbon Caramel

Matty's Hot Sauce

Fat Toad Caramel - Cold Brew Coffee

Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce

Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce

High Desert Sauce Co

Maple Gingersnaps

Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce

Raspberry Almond Cookies

Rancho Gordo

Mulled Cider Caramel 8oz

Peppercorn Porter Hot Sauce

Queen Majesty Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce, 5oz

Fishwife

GusterNola - Miller Mix

Murder Hornet Hot Sauce

Mulled Cider Caramel

Petit Quartet Goats Milk Caramel Set

Gustard - A Guster Mustard

HEATONIST

Scape Sauce

Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

Maple Rum Chipotle Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce

Ooh La La - A Guster Hot Sauce

2oz Spicy Dark Chocolate Goat's Milk Caramel

Peanut Maple Vanilla Granola

Olive My Pickle

• SALAD DRESSING KIT •

Smoked Serrano Squash Reaper X Hot Sauce

Vermont Maple Caramel

Claire's Maple Reserve Goat's Milk Caramel

Cold Brew Coffee Caramel

Toccata Hot Sauce - 5 oz.

Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce - 5oz

Sweet Quartet Petit Caramel Sampler

Smoked Onion Salsa

Maple Spice Snaps

Habanero Heady Craft Beer Hot Sauce

Tomatillo Chipotle Salsa

Petit Goats Milk Caramel | Salted Bourbon

Maple Sriracha Mustard

Dies Irae (Day of Wrath) Hot Sauce

Vermont Jalapeno Mustard

Fat Toad Farm Caramel - Butterfly Bakery

DIY Caramel Apple Kit

Queen Majesty Hot Sauce - Scotch Bonnet & Ginger Hot Sauce, 5 Fl Oz (2 Pack) - All Natural, Vegan, Gluten Free, Sugar Free, Made in the USA, Featured

Signature Hot Sauce Sampler

TorchBearer Sauces

Mellow Vibes Only Hot Sauce

Burlap & Barrel

Ghost Verde Pickle Genersaucity Hot Sauce

Heat

Maple Coffee Hot Sauce

myspicebuds

Super Hot Odds and Ends Hot Sauce

Wildfish Cannery