Build your assortment of fresh New York City bagels by selecting 4 options from our 22 available flavors.
Note: This package includes options to order Everything, Onion or Garlic bagels. The intense garlic or onion aroma of these flavors ma...
Reviews
4.8
5.7K ratings
5
4
3
2
1
To be really honest, I’ve had many bagels in my lifetime. But I made the decision seeing this New York bagels on Facebook. I’d give it a shot. I can’t tell you how happy I did. I thought I knew what a bagel was supposed to taste like, but not until I ordered these and I’ve ordered every flavor. It is the most outstanding tastiest chewy yummy bagel I have ever had in my life since then I have now ordered multiple orders. I can say that there’s not one bagel in any grocery store or deli that I’ve ever had that comes even close to this bagel company so if you haven’t tried it, you will not regret it. Follow the instructions though very important to get the best tasting bagel ever.
S
Sharon · 2 days ago
Still great bagels.
The bagels are right on par. However, FedEx gave us a scare and we’re going to delay delivery until Monday instead of Saturday. Thankfully they changed their minds and delivered on time. You should have a couple of new customers for California soon.
W
William · 2 days ago
Oh, if I only had more freezer space!
I typically buy these bagels 2 dozen at a time. I'd buy more if I had the room! They are delicious. I love how they're crispy on the outside, while lighter inside. I am especially pleased with the fact that they use no preservatives. If I ever start to take their quality for granted, all I need to do is taste another brand of bagel and be reminded of how much better these are.