Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate-covered peanut butter buckeye fudge balls white plate, with a spoonful of peanut butter

Butter Maid Bakery

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$22.99$26.00

12% off

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

You might also like

Clothespin lady lock cookies with powdered sugar on a white plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

(728)

Nut Kolachi Cookies on Closeup - Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Nut Kolachi Cookies aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

(204)

creamy peanut butter dipped in smooth milk chocolate to look like the real Buckeye nut.

Marie’s Candies

Buckeyes

(8)

Sarris Candies

Sarris Candies

Sarris Candies

5

(634)

Holiday red and green sprinkle sugar butter cookies with white chocolate chips, on a white plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Holiday Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

(47)

Mister Ed's Elephant Museum & Candy Emporium

Homemade Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Forbes Candies

Buckeyes

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll - Kringle Strudel Kolache Povitica - on a plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll

(40)

True Delicious

True Delicious

4.6

(4.3K)

A jar of True Delicious Pumpkin Spice Biscotti with Glaze & Pepitas sits atop a wooden table, accompanied by tea, a bowl of pepitas, a biscotti-filled plate, and autumn decor such as pumpkins and colorful leaves. Each piece is made from natural ingredients to highlight the comforting flavors of fall.

A jar of True Delicious Pumpkin Spice Biscotti with Glaze & Pepitas sits atop a wooden table, accompanied by tea, a bowl of pepitas, a biscotti-filled plate, and autumn decor such as pumpkins and colorful leaves. Each piece is made from natural ingredients to highlight the comforting flavors of fall.

A wooden bowl of True Delicious Cranberry Orange Biscotti - Special Batch sits next to orange sauce, cranberries, orange slices, and a biscuit tin on a rustic table—creating the perfect handcrafted biscotti moment.

A bowl of True Delicious Cranberry Pistachio Biscotti - Limited Edition sits beside dried cranberries and pistachios, beautifully arranged on a marble surface to showcase this handcrafted treat.

A white dish holds powdered sugar-coated Amaretti Cookies from True Delicious, next to a clear container labeled “Amaretti Cookies—Soft Almond Cookies, No Gluten”—delicious gluten-free treats made with almond flour.

Blueberry kolachi roll pastry with fresh blueberries on a white plate, with a rolling pin in the background.

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Blueberry Jam Kolachi Roll

(60)

Poppy seed raisin filled kolachi roll sliced on a baker's scale

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

(31)

Nut & Seed Kolachi Variety

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Nut & Seed Kolachi Variety

(19)

Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Truffle-Violet Glass Apothecary Jar (up to 75 cups)-Magic Hour

Magic Hour

Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Truffle

(75)

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll - Slice - Potica Kolache Beigli Povitica

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll

(726)

David's Cookies

David's Cookies

4.5

(6.3K)

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Nuts To You

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(16)

A closeup of apricot filled kolachi roll on a cutting board

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Apricot Filled Kolachi Roll

(112)

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll on bakers scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll

(102)

Sweet Designs Chocolatier

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(3)

Angelino's Coffee

4.8

(75K)

A close-up of a sliced sweet cream cheese filled kolachi roll pastry, shown in front of wrapped cream cheese package and rolling pin

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Cream Cheese Kolachi Roll

(93)

A clear plastic container holding slices of kolachi roll pastry on a marble countertop

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Kolachi Slice Box

(107)

Chocolate Clothespin Cookies - Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns close up on plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate Clothespin Cookies - Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

(9)

Chocolate Monkey

Buckeye

(1)

City Pop

City Pop

4.6

(23.9K)

City Pop Patriot Mix Popcorn Bowl

City Pop Patriot Mix Popcorn Bowl

Caramel Pecan Popcorn

Caramel Cashew Popcorn

Toffee Almond Popcorn

Exclusive deal available

Fresh Roasted Coffee

Tanzanian Peaberry Coffee - Aviv Estate - Roasted Coffee

(589)

Boarderie

4.7

(50.2K)

Small Halloween dessert board with assorted chocolate truffles, brownie bites, and candy in a gold-lined wooden tray, featuring a "Happy Halloween" chocolate plaque and a personalized wooden mallet.

Small Halloween dessert board with assorted chocolate truffles, brownie bites, and candy in a gold-lined wooden tray, featuring a "Happy Halloween" chocolate plaque and a personalized wooden mallet.

Small dessert gift box with "Happy Birthday" chocolate card, decorated bonbons, cake slices, chocolate-covered berries, and candied fruits on marble surface

A wooden gift box filled with assorted Halloween-themed treats, including macarons, halloween themed truffles, decorated chocolate candies, candy corn, spiderweb toffee, and a chocolate smash box that says 'Happy Halloween.' The box is styled on a marble surface with purple curtains in the background.

Poppy Seed Filled Kolachi Roll - Potica Beigli Makowiec Kolache Povitica on baker's scale

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Poppy Seed Filled Kolachi Roll

(383)

A close-up pile of sea salted caramel chocolate cookies with a broken in half gooey center of melted caramel

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies

(228)

Honey Walnut Kolachi Roll - Potica Povitica Beigli Kolache

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Honey Walnut Kolachi Roll

(141)

Wildgrain

Wildgrain

Wildgrain

4.7

(79.3K)

Angled view of Wildgrain box showcasing three croissants inside with scattered macadamia nuts on white background

Angled view of Wildgrain box showcasing three croissants inside with scattered macadamia nuts on white background

Top-down view of Slow-Fermented Protein Ciabatta (16oz) showing crusty, flour-dusted exterior and rustic scoring on a blue wood table with striped linen

Close-up of 4 dozen croissants showcasing flaky layered pastries with 48x text over a blue background

Overhead view of giant chocolate chunk cookies showcasing 30% chocolate chunks, with 60x text on blue wood

Exclusive deal available

Chocolate Emporium

Buckeyes

Raspberry jam filled kolachi roll sliced on a serving plate with fresh raspberries, on a holiday table

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Raspberry Jam Kolachi Roll

(92)

Kolachi Roll Sampler - Apple Cinnamon Jam, Walnut, Poppy Seed - Served Sliced on a Stone Cutting Board

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Kolachi Sampler - Apple Cinnamon Jam, Walnut, Poppy Seed

(7)

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll on a baker's scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache Povitica

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll

(64)

Licorice.com

Licorice.com

Licorice.com

4.4

(91.7K)

Treat yourself to the deliciousness of this premium licorice.

Sweet As Fudge

Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes (12 oz)

(4)

Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll - Potica Kolache Kringle Povitica plated

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Pumpkin Walnut Kolachi Roll

(19)

Exclusive deal available

Hero

Sliced White Bread

(5.7K)

Several powdered sugar-coated toasted walnut butterball cookies on a wooden serving board on a woven table mat, with a russian tea cake cookie broken open to show a crumbly inside

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Butterballs - Toasted Walnut Cookies

(242)

A close-up of chocolate chip cookies on a bright pink background, with one cookie broken in front to show melted chocolate chips

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate Chip Cookies

(154)

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons - Military Care Package APO FPO DPO

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

(106)

Italian rainbow cake tricolor bites close up plated, also widely known a neopolitan petit fours cookies

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Italian Rainbow Cake Bites

(211)

Chocolate walnut kolachi roll sliced on a marble cutting board. Also called Povitica Potica Beigli Kolache

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate Walnut Kolachi Roll

(84)

Uncle Butch's Fudge

4.7

(22.6K)

Salted Caramel Drizzled Coconut Macaroons - Military Care Package APO FPO DPO

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Salted Caramel Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

(46)

Fall sprinkle sugar butter cookies, close up of warm gooey cookie broken in half

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Fall Sprinkle Sugar Butter Cookies

Kolachi Roll Sampler - Walnut, Apricot, Pecan - sliced on board

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Kolachi Sampler - Walnut, Apricot, Pecan

(39)

Kolachi Roll Sampler - Raspberry Jam, Walnut, Pecan - Served Sliced on Cutting Board

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Kolachi Sampler - Raspberry Jam, Walnut, Pecan

(31)

Polana Polish Food Online

4.5

(2.1K)

Shipping Cooler With Dry Ice (Required) - Polana

Shipping Cooler With Dry Ice (Required) - Polana

Polish Rye Bread - Polana

Military Cookie Care Package - Ships to APO FPO DPO - Butter Maid Bakery

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Military Cookie Care Package

(8)

Exclusive deal available

Buckeye Brownies

Perfectly Peanut Butter Cookies

(35)

Brand Spotlight: Fishwife

Tinned fish, but make it gourmet.

Cinnamon Pecan Kolachi Cookies sprinkled with cinnamon sugar, on a plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Cinnamon Pecan Kolachi Cookies

(126)

Bedtime tea ritual

Bedtime tea ritual

Chamomile, mint, rooibos, and honey add-ins.

Cranberry Walnut Kolachi Roll with diced cranberry chunks, on a white plate

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Cranberry Walnut Kolachi Roll

(74)

Apple Cinnamon Walnut Kolachi Roll sliced on a cutting board

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Apple Cinnamon Walnut Kolachi Roll

(81)

Handcrafted Peanut Butter Chocolate Buckeye - Full Circle Gifts & Goods

Full Circle Gifts & Goods

Handcrafted Peanut Butter Chocolate Buckeye

A pile of golden-brown sugar butter cookies on a white plate, with one cookie broken open to show the gooey middle.

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Sugar Butter Cookies

(97)

FreshCut Paper

FreshCut Paper

4.8

(63.5K)

A person in a cream knit sweater holds a vibrant paper floral arrangement in a ribbed orange pumpkin-shaped vase. The bouquet features bright yellow sunflowers, red and pink flowers, white blossoms, and green leaves with small red berries.

Prune lekvar filled kolachi roll pastry sliced on a baker's scale

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Prune Lekvar Filled Kolachi Roll

(41)

Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll on cutting board - Potica Beigli Kolache Kringle

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Raspberry Walnut Kolachi Roll

(22)

Sarris Candies

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(8)

Exclusive deal available

David's Cookies

Thank You Butter Pecan Meltaways

(2)

ROYO BREAD CO.

4.3

(77.1K)

Apricot Kolachi Cookies Closeup - Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Apricot Kolachi Cookies aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

(381)

Konstantin Zsigo | Chocolatier

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

(56)

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Plated - Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

(223)

Pecan kolachi kringle roll sliced on a baker's scale with in-shell pecans and whole pecans

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Pecan Kolachi Roll

(127)

Elevated sandwich essentials

Elevated sandwich essentials

Breads, pickles, and tinned fish.

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes Bulk - Gretel's Candy

Gretel's Candy

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes Bulk

Reduced Sugar Walnut Kolachi Roll - Potica Kolache Beigli Povitica

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Reduced Sugar Walnut Kolachi Roll

(64)

A walnut and raisin filled kolachi roll pastry, sliced on a white surface

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Walnut & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

(58)

Pretzels.com

4.2

(47.4K)

Birthday cake confetti cookies on a white plate with rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips. A cookie broken in half to show the gooey middle

Exclusive deal available

Butter Maid Bakery

Birthday Cake Confetti Cookies

(38)

Exclusive deal available

Buckeye Brownies

Mr Buckeye 4-Pack

(159)

The Basket Company, Inc.

Peanut Butter Buckeyes

eat well celebrations and feasts

Buckeye Brownies