Peanut Butter Buckeyes

Name: Butter Maid Bakery Peanut Butter Buckeyes - Peanut Butter Buckeyes
Brand: Butter Maid Bakery
SKU: 32109759725706
Price: 22.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.8123 (209 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$22.99$26.00

12% off

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

Description

☀️🍫 Warm Weather Shipping Warning: Chocolate-coated treats may arrive soft or melted - but still delicious! Refrigerate or freeze to restore firmness. Want to avoid melting? - Affordable 2-Day Expedited Shipping is available at checkout. K...

Reviews

4.8

405 ratings

The buckeyes are absolutely delicious. I only wish they were smaller and there were more of them. They are quite large to eat at one time. I would definitely order them again.

Jodi · June 10, 2026

Sinfully delicious!

Bruce · August 21, 2026

The buckeyes arrived perfect - at least we thought so. When we.reached in to eat, they were soft and warm… and probably the best Buckeyes my roommate or I had ever had! Seriously! Try a warm buckeye…its amazing! The cookies were (are!) great. I love soft cookies and they fit the bill perfectly. Sweet and buttery…ill get them again! Thank you for the fast shipping. Everything arrived in perfect condition and is being enjoyed by all!

Diana · May 20, 2026

Delivery & Returns

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

4.7 (6.4K)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Clothespin lady lock cookies with powdered sugar on a white plate

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Clothespin Cookies aka Lady Locks, Fingers, Cream Horns

(719)

$28.99$34.00

Nut Kolachi Cookies on Closeup - Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Nut Kolachi Cookies aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

(198)

$28.99$34.00

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons - Military Care Package APO FPO DPO

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Chocolate Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

(100)

$22.99$26.00

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll on bakers scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Lemon Cream Kolachi Roll

(100)

$25.99$32.00

Salted Caramel Drizzled Coconut Macaroons - Military Care Package APO FPO DPO

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Salted Caramel Drizzled Coconut Macaroons

(44)

$22.99$26.00

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Kolachi Slice Box

(105)

$19.99$28.00

Forbes Candies

Buckeyes

$26.99

Birthday Cake Confetti Funfetti Sprinkle Cookies

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Birthday Cake Confetti Cookies

(38)

$19.99$24.00

Gretel's Candy

Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes Bulk

$14.98

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Military Cookie Care Package

(7)

$39.99$48.00

Exclusive offer available

Magic Hour

Pumpkin Spice Chocolate Truffle

(69)

$11.00

My Favorite Sweet Shoppe Pittsburgh

Chocolate Buckeyes

$11.99

Exclusive offer available

Vibrant Meals

PB Buckeye Bars

(2)

$5.99

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll - Slice - Potica Kolache Beigli Povitica

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

The Original Nut Kolachi Roll

(720)

$25.99$32.00

A close-up pile of sea salted caramel chocolate cookies with a broken in half gooey center of melted caramel

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Sea Salted Caramel Chocolate Cookies

(225)

$19.99$24.00

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies Plated - Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Raspberry Kolachi Cookies aka Kolacky, Kolaczki, Kiffles

(220)

$28.99$34.00

Pecan Kolachi Roll - Kringle Potica Beigli Kolache

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Pecan Kolachi Roll

(126)

$25.99$32.00

A pile of golden-brown sugar butter cookies on a white plate, with one cookie broken open to show the gooey middle.

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Sugar Butter Cookies

(94)

$19.99$24.00

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll on a baker's scale - Kringle Strudel Kolache Povitica

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Apple Cinnamon Jam Kolachi Roll

(62)

$25.99$32.00

Taco Tuesday favorites

Tortillas, slaws, and salsas.

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll - Beigli Makowiec Potica

Exclusive offer available

Butter Maid Bakery

Poppy Seed & Raisin Filled Kolachi Roll

(30)

$25.99$32.00

Exclusive offer available

Buckeye Brownies

Mr Buckeye 4-Pack

(155)

$32.00

Sarris Candies

Peanut Butter Meltaways

(15)

$18.95

The Basket Company, Inc.