Send a gift of fresh NYC bagels – always baked to order and shipped with free 2-day shipping included with purchase!
A discount is applied to every subscription order.
Details
1 dozen large NYC bagels, boiled 'n baked in NYC
Shipped fresh ...
Reviews
4.6
47 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Bagel of the Month Gift - 3 Months
J
Jennifer · April 22, 2026
Bagel of the Month Gift - 3 Months
L
Lexi · March 9, 2026
Sorry, not the same bagels you get from a local NYC bagel establishment.
The bagels I received were too bready and far too sweet. A bagel should have a firm outter crust that isn't rock hard, and a dense, yet yielding inner texture. These barely had a crust, as if they were not boiled at all before baking. I really was hoping to get some great NY bagels, but they are closer to Lenders in my opinion.