This is the product description text that will appear here.
Quantity
1
One time purchase
$14.99
Subscribe & save
Save 10%
$13.49$14.99
Delivers every 3 weeks
So good, it’s scary.
Our newest indulgence is here to haunt your cravings — in the best way possible.
Oatmeal Scream Pie Peanut Butter is a spooky-sweet twist on your favorite childhood treat, blending creamy peanut butter with warm oatmeal...
Reviews
4.6
33 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
The Oatmeal butter was ok. There was one whole, in-tact, oatmeal pie in the jar drowned in PB. The PB taste over powers the oatmeal pie. I added more oatmeal pies of my own to balance it out. The M is for Monster tasted like the stale cookies inside. Glad I ordered the sampler of that one.
McArthur · May 21, 2026
We bought four different flavors. We’ve bought from them before. I don’t know if they’re trying to cut costs or what one of the cookie butters the monster cookie butter mix was a extremely scant topping in it. It was like 90% just peanut butter. And more watery than what I remember.
Amanda · April 17, 2026
This is soo good , the flavor , the toppings are outstanding !!