Evelyn Retro Oxfords (Tan/Brown)

Gorgeous, quality, true to size, comfy

I LOVE these shoes SO much. Omg, they're so gorgeous, truly. They look exactly as on the website. The materials are good quality, they're very sturdy & look beautiful. I love the shape of the shoe, seems very historically accurate to me, but these can be worn with modern clothes, too. I just ordered the Karolina shoes because these were so beautiful. I'm 7.5 and they fit perfectly. Shipping was very quick, everything was smooth.

These are lovely shoes with beautiful vintage styling, the soles are also fully padded, so I really wanted to be able to give them 5 stars, but they're way too narrow and too short.

Fits narrow and small

Lovely silhouette, but unlike my several other American Duchess shoes, these run quite narrow and short. Even if I sized up, I don’t know that the pinched toe box would resolve.