Sam Lucky Penny Leather Loafers

They are alright!

I reallyyyyyy wanted to love these. I had seen them on TikTok and thought I’d finally found something meant for me. I have had them for a few months now; they’re my daily drivers, and I now feel informed enough to review them. Overall, they are comfortable and I certainly appreciate the extended sizing. The toe box is nice and comfy so my toes aren’t crowded, the soles they provide are comfy, and the quality of the outside of the shoe seems great. I also like that they provide an extra set of soles. My biggest issue with loafers is how thick my feet are. Most times if I order them in my size (11), they’re way too tight at the lip of the shoe. Removing the sole doesn’t help enough. I ended up exchanging them for a size 12, which fit, but I sound like I’m wearing flip flops when I walk. Their customer service was easy enough to correspond with and offered to help with choosing the right size. It sounds like you only get one free exchange/return (maybe per order), which I don’t love. I look forward to trying their sandals. In the meantime, I’m going to try their back of heel cushions to see if that helps with the extra space.

The penny is a no from me

Looks very cheap and not very comfortable. Tight across the top of my foot and gave me horrible blisters on my heel

Love my shoes