Let Us Make the Tough Choices for You 😉
Big life decisions are hard — but picking a marshmallow flavor shouldn’t be! With our Mystery Marshmallow Pack, you leave the choice to us. We’ll surprise you with one delicious, handcrafted flavor, freshly picked from our gourmet lineup.
It’s a fun way to add a little mystery to your day (and mayb
3.9
10 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
The flavor grapefruit I’m allergic to grapefruit
R
Rachel · September 19, 2026
Not my flavor but still a GREAT mallow
Did not love this flavor- but I am not a coconut girl so it just wasn’t for me. Fun to get a mystery flavor though and I am SURE this is someone’s favorite hence the 4 starts! The minus a star because if you don’t love coconut this one is coconut heavy.