Butterfly Bakery - Hot Sauce Sampler 6 pk

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Green Mountain Goodness Maple Seasoning

(5)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Fat Toad Caramel - Mulled Cider

$7.50

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Jed's Maple - Maple Jelly

(1)

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Signature Sextet Gift Box

$95.00

ENZO'S TABLE

4.8

(273)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Make Your Own Donuts

(6)

$19.95

My Dad's Cookies

Dad's Favorite Variety Pack — 12 Full-Size

$79.95

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Thumbprint Cookies

(24)

Exclusive offer available

Vermont's Own Gifts & Goods

Hot Sauce - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

$8.99

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Chipotles In Adobo Hot Sauce

(2)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Sugar Bob's - Vermont Maple Sriracha

My Dad's Cookies

Better Crumbs: Panko Style Bread Crumbs (Italian Herb)

(2)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Hard Cider Onion Mustard

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Richard's - Hottest BBQ Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Heady Topper Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Snack Attack Pack

$74.95

Cabot Creamery

(692)

An 8 oz package of Cabot Creamery Wildly Horseradish Cheddar Cheese with a purple and cream label, highlighting its zesty horseradish cheddar flavor.

A 1 lb (453g) block of Cabot Creamery Vintage Choice Cheddar Cheese, aged 24 months, in black packaging with a cream and purple label, labeled Classic Vermont.

Cabot Creamery 5 Year Cheddar Cheese, limited reserve, naturally aged for five years, comes in a 1 lb (453g) block with a black and cream label and offers an intense, complex bold cheddar flavor.

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Grafton Village Cheese Sampler Gift Pack

$48.95

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Smoked Onion Maple Habanero Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Maple Honey Vinegar

My Dad's Cookies

Sprinkle Cookies

(11)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

& Maple - Turkey Brine

$23.95

8% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Signature Hot Sauce Sampler

(7)

$35.00$38.00

20% off

SCOVILLED

Butterfly Bakery Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

(5)

$11.99$15.00

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Bread & Butter Pickle Hot Sauce

(1)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Heady Topper Mustard

Northwest Wild Foods

4.9

(2.7K)

SCOVILLED

Butterfly Bakery Hot House Hot Sauce

$10.00

American Spoon

4.9

(3.7K)

A jar of Early Glow Strawberry Preserves

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Cilantro Onion Hot Sauce

(5)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Richard's - Hot BBQ Sauce

My Dad's Cookies

6oz Flavor Adventure Assortment - 3 Count

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Maple Sugar Granules

(17)

$24.95

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Maple Coffee Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Homemade Apple Pie & Cheddar Cheese

(1)

$44.95

My Dad's Cookies

6oz Linzer Assortment - 3 Count

(1)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butternut Maple Pepper w/ Garlic

(1)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Vermont Farmstead Maple Cheddar Cheese

(4)

$10.50

Scottish Gourmet USA

4.8

(1.3K)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Vermont Habs Hot Sauce

My Dad's Cookies

2oz Kids' Favorites Assortment - 3 Count

$11.55

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

$15.95

Chile Mojo

Hot House Hot Sauce by Butterfly Bakery of Vermont - 148ml (5oz)

$19.00

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Sugar Bob's Savory Sampler Pack

$36.95

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Elderflower Ghost Hot Sauce

$15.95

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Grafton - Smoked Chili Cheddar

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Richard's - Mild BBQ Sauce

(3)

SCOVILLED

Butterfly Bakery Habanero Lime Switchback Craft Beer Hot Sauce

$9.00

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Richard's - Chicken Marinade

My Dad's Cookies

6oz Kids' Favorites Assortment - 3 Count

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Maple Horseradish Mustard

(8)

$5.95

Exclusive offer available

Vermont's Own Gifts & Goods

Signature Hot Sauce Sampler Box Set - Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

$33.99

27% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Red Ghost Reaper Hot Sauce

(8)

$11.00$15.00

Menus and Music

4.8

(477)

Set of Two Boxes: Pecan and Meyer Lemon Shortbread Cookies

My Dad's Cookies

Vanilla Linzer Trio

(5)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Garlic Scape Hot Sauce

Collage of hot sauce bottles, peppers, and a cracker with cheese and hot sauce on it.

11% off

Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Hot Sauce of the Season

(2)

$156.00$176.00

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Habanero Lime Switchback Hot Sauce

a bottle of maple sugar shack sriracha on a dark wood table surrounded by red serrano and jalepeno peppers with a maple leaf shaped bottle of maple syrup behind it

NewEngland.com Store

Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Honey Vinegar

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Green Mountain Goodness Maple Sprinkles

(1)

$14.95

Back-to-school breakfast

Pancake mixes, yogurt, and seed butters.

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Legendary Cider Donuts

(212)

$12.95

My Dad's Cookies

Dad's Favorite Variety Pack — 12 Mini Size

(2)

$41.99

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Apple-A-Day Coffee Cake

(9)

$22.95

Common Deer

Hot Sauce Sampler Box of 6 Minis

$34.00

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery Ghost Verde Pickle Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Maple Wood Smoked Onion Hot Sauce

My Dad's Cookies

6oz Chocolate Lover's Assortment - 3 Count

(1)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Sugar Bob's - Smoked Maple Sriracha

Butterfly Bakery Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce 5 oz.

13% off

The Pepper Pantry

Butterfly Bakery Maple Sugar Shack Sriracha Hot Sauce 5 oz.

$10.00$11.50

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Richard's - Hot Sauce

(1)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Jed's Maple - Sugar Shakers

$9.95

My Dad's Cookies

Lemon Burst Linzers

(8)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Maple Apple Drizzle

(6)

$9.95

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Cold Hollow - Jack Frost Maple Syrup

(1)

$34.95

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery - Habanero Heady Hot Sauce

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Apple Balsamic Vinegar

(1)

$15.95

My Dad's Cookies

2oz Linzer Assortment - 3 Count

$11.55

Elevated sandwich essentials

Breads, pickles, and tinned fish.

NewEngland.com Store

Taco Vibes Only Hot Sauce

$16.95

Butterfly Bakery Maple Coffee Hot Sauce - Main Image

Exclusive offer available

Chilly Chiles

Butterfly Bakery Maple Coffee Hot Sauce

$14.00

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Butterfly Bakery Maple Rum Chipotle Hot Sauce

My Dad's Cookies

Raspberry Linzer

(10)

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Sugar Bob's - Jalapeño Maple Sriracha

(1)