This is the product description text that will appear here.
Quantity
1
One time purchase
$12.49
Subscribe & save
Save 10%
$11.24$12.49
Delivers every 2 weeks
Indulge in the creamy, smooth taste of our Vanilla Cone-y (Island) Salt Water Taffy. Offering a simple yet sophisticated vanilla flavor, this taffy is always a favorite. Its rich, buttery notes and chewy texture create a timeless candy expe...
Reviews
4.7
29 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Very good
I love, Love the taffy shop products. The vanilla tasted a little plastic-y. I think it just needs a little something to brighten it. Peppermint and cinnamon are my favoritea. We need a good coconut cream flavor along the lines of the peppermint. Mellow with an almost buttery finish.
R
Rebecca · April 18, 2026
The taffy has no taste
J
Joe · May 22, 2026
I loved it, especially since I live in Coney Island. You did it right