Caramel Witch

Name: Fat Witch New York Caramel Witch - Caramel Witch
Brand: Fat Witch New York
SKU: 50575548023105
Price: 5.6 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4 (1 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$5.60

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

Description

The Caramel Witch swirls buttery caramel into rich chocolate brownie for a sweet, smooth finish in every bite.

Reviews

4.0

4 ratings

I have the cookbook and i adore the recipes. I wanted to try them direct from the source! Sadly, they all tasted stale. So disappointing.

Andra · February 21, 2026

Delivery & Returns

Fat Witch New York

4.9 (82)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Fat Witch New York

Double Chocolate Witch

(3)

$5.60

Fat Witch New York

Coffee Witch

(1)

$5.60

Fat Witch New York

Apple Cinnamon Baby

(2)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Salted Caramel Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Blonde Baby

(1)

$3.50

Rise & Puff

4.7

(6.8K)

Rise & Puff Quesadilla Variety Pack with Turkey Bacon — frozen handheld quesadilla pouches including Chipotle Chicken, Pizza Uncured Pepperoni, BBQ Chicken, Ooey Gooey Cheese, Pesto & Goat Cheese, Beef Brisket, Ham Egg & Cheese, Bacon Egg & Cheese, and Turkey Sausage & Cheese

Rise & Puff Pizza Uncured Pepperoni Quesadilla — frozen handheld pizza quesadilla with uncured pepperoni, part-skim mozzarella and pizza sauce on a thin tortilla crust

Rise & Puff Chipotle Chicken Quesadilla — frozen handheld quesadilla with pulled white-meat chicken, aged cheddar, Monterey Jack and mozzarella

Rise & Puff Turkey Sausage & Cheese Breakfast Quesadilla — frozen handheld with turkey sausage and reduced-fat cheddar cheese

Fat Witch New York

9 Baby All Star

$32.00

Fat Witch New York

Tiny Bag B&W

$9.00

At the Chapel

Salted Caramel Brownie

$6.00

Candy Funhouse US

Kit Kat Witch's Brew Snack Size with Marshmallow Flavoured Creme - 9.8

$10.49

Caramels.com

Caramel Brownie Collection

(7)

$79.00

Top Luxury Caramel Awards 2017 Bronze — Peanut Caramel Cup, Best Ingredient Combination (TasteTV).

The Secret Chocolatier

Peanut Caramel Cups

(1)

$27.00

a chewy caramel center covered in smooth milk chocolate or rich dark chocolate in a pound box.

Marie’s Candies

Caramels - 1 lb.

$30.50

Thick rectangular bars enrobed in dark chocolate are stacked together. The bars have diagonal stripes piped in chocolate on the tops. One bar is cut in half revealing the layers of jellied raspberry and creamy peanut butter inside.

Li-Lac Chocolates

PB&J Bars

(26)

$23.75

Fat Witch New York

Fat Witch

(3)

$5.60

Fat Witch New York

Red Baby

(1)

$3.50

Baked by Melissa

4.9

(285)

Fat Witch New York

Yuzu Baby

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Fat Witch Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Hot Coco Trio

$24.00

Fat Witch New York

Classic Cauldron Special

$28.00

Fat Witch New York

Summer Cauldron

$28.00

a chewy caramel center covered in smooth milk chocolate or rich dark chocolate in a half pound box.

Marie’s Candies

Caramels - 1/2 lb.

(1)

$15.25

Stage Stop Candy

Chocolate Witch

(1)

$2.50

ScuttleButter Bakery

Brownies with Salted Caramel

$4.50

Minnie Beasley’s

4.6

(4.9K)

The Secret Chocolatier

Chocolate Marshmallows

$7.50

The Secret Chocolatier

Dark Chocolate Caramels with Sea Salt

(3)

$45.60

Levain Bakery

4.7

(908)

Signature Cookie Assortment - Levain Bakery

Levain Cookie Tin Bundle - Levain Bakery

Suprise Assortment - Cookie Club - Levain Bakery

Fat Witch New York

Lemon Baby

(2)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Double Chocolate Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Snow Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Brownie Mix Original

(1)

$8.50

Fat Witch New York

Brownie Bites

$5.00

Small dollops of milk chocolate sit together.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Chocolate Drops

(29)

$16.00

Genesee Candy Land

Chocolate Walnut Fudge

$6.50

The MACCS

4.6

(613)

6. Amarena Cherry Maccs.jpg__PID:af39ed77-a8e8-4283-94d9-05c8fec48f3c

13. Hazelnut Maccs.jpg__PID:08eaf2d4-7080-4687-a491-baa9d32965be

A large rectangular box of chocolate with a brown base and a purple lid with watercolor lilac motifs.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Home Assortment (12.5 oz.)

(20)

$52.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

20 pc. French Assortment (Chocolate Gift Box, 2 Layers, 1/2 lb.)

(75)

$38.00

Adventurous Chocolate 9-piece box — bonbons with hand-painted decorative patterns in gold and red, featuring bold exotic flavors.

The Secret Chocolatier

A Little Adventurous

(2)

$27.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

Raspberry Creams

(15)

$40.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

Butter Crunch

(119)

$23.00

Fat Witch New York

Snow Witch

(4)

$5.60

Hosting chips and dip night

Herby dips, scoop chips, and kettle classics.

Fat Witch New York

Caramel Baby

(1)

$3.50

Li-Lac Chocolates

Walnut Caramel Bars

(39)

$28.50

Fat Witch New York

American Flag Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Big Witch Box

$43.00

Assorted milk and white chocolate bars with almonds

Li-Lac Chocolates

Chocolate Almond Bark

(44)

$46.00

saltedbakedgoods

Salted Caramel Brownie

(8)

$6.88

Virginia Diner

Caramel Brownie

$13.45

Recchiuti Confections

4.8

(1.8K)

Thin pretzels, enrobed in milk and dark chocolate, are stacked together.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Chocolate Pretzels

(35)

$20.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

4" Champagne Mini

(8)

$8.00

A cellophane bag of Dark Chocolate Nonpareils.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Dark Chocolate Nonpareils (8 oz. Bag)

(27)

$16.00

Rich Brownies & Puckies

Salted Caramel Brownie (One,4oz)

$6.00

Fat Witch New York

Blonde Witch

(2)

$5.60

Fat Witch New York

Coconut Baby

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Sesame Baby

(1)

$3.50

Thick bars of marshmallow enrobed in dark chocolate are lined up together. The bars are cut so that you can see the soft white marshmallow inside.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Marshmallow Bars

(64)

$28.50

Taco Tuesday favorites

Tortillas, slaws, and salsas.

Fat Witch New York

Witchy Tiny Bags

$63.00

Fat Witch New York

4 Baby Summer Tin

$19.00

Fashion Flare Boutique

Chocolate Walnut Fudge

$6.50

25% off

WellEasy

Fatt Chocolate + Caramel Bites 35g

$3.00$4.00

Genesee Candy Land

Chocolate Heath® Crumble Fudge

$6.50

A cellophane bag of Milk Chocolate Malt Balls.

Li-Lac Chocolates

Milk Chocolate Malt Balls (7 oz. Bag)

(37)

$16.00

Li-Lac Chocolates

Star Pop

(8)

$4.25

Uncle Butch's Fudge

4.7

(21K)

Fat Witch New York

Walnut Witch

(1)

$5.60

Fat Witch New York

Almond Baby

(3)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Walnut Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Matcha Baby

(1)

$3.50

Fat Witch New York

Witch Ends Fat Witch Original

(1)

$7.00

Fat Witch New York

4 Baby Gift Tin

$19.00

Fat Witch New York

5 Pack Fat Witch Coffee

$9.00

Instant noodle upgrades

Noodles, chili crisp, and broth boosters.

Strossner's

Salted Caramel Brownie

(1)

$3.00

The Secret Chocolatier

Caramel-oh!

(1)

$27.00

Bella The Corner Gourmet

Toffee 8oz Bag - Toffee - Chocolate Covered

$19.99

A thick square of marshmallow sandwiched between graham crackers, enrobed in milk or dark chocolate are stacked together. One S’more is cut in half, revealing the marshmallow and graham cracker inside.

Li-Lac Chocolates

All-American S'mores

(36)

$25.50

Li-Lac Chocolates

Peanut Butter Cups

(40)

$24.00

Caramel Witch

Reviews

Delivery & Returns

Fat Witch New York

Reviews

Delivery & Returns

Fat Witch New York

You might also like

Double Chocolate Witch

Coffee Witch

Apple Cinnamon Baby

Salted Caramel Baby

Blonde Baby

Rise & Puff

9 Baby All Star

Tiny Bag B&W

Salted Caramel Brownie

Kit Kat Witch's Brew Snack Size with Marshmallow Flavoured Creme - 9.8

Caramel Brownie Collection

Peanut Caramel Cups

Caramels - 1 lb.

PB&J Bars

Fat Witch

Red Baby

Baked by Melissa

Yuzu Baby

Fat Witch Baby

Hot Coco Trio

Classic Cauldron Special

Summer Cauldron

Caramels - 1/2 lb.

Chocolate Witch

Brownies with Salted Caramel

Minnie Beasley’s

Chocolate Marshmallows

Dark Chocolate Caramels with Sea Salt

Levain Bakery

Lemon Baby

Double Chocolate Baby

Snow Baby

Brownie Mix Original

Brownie Bites

Chocolate Drops

Chocolate Walnut Fudge

The MACCS

Home Assortment (12.5 oz.)

20 pc. French Assortment (Chocolate Gift Box, 2 Layers, 1/2 lb.)

A Little Adventurous

Raspberry Creams

Butter Crunch

Snow Witch

Caramel Baby

Walnut Caramel Bars

American Flag Baby

Big Witch Box

Chocolate Almond Bark

Salted Caramel Brownie

Caramel Brownie

Recchiuti Confections

Chocolate Pretzels

4" Champagne Mini

Dark Chocolate Nonpareils (8 oz. Bag)

Salted Caramel Brownie (One,4oz)

Blonde Witch

Coconut Baby

Sesame Baby

Marshmallow Bars

Witchy Tiny Bags

4 Baby Summer Tin

Chocolate Walnut Fudge

Fatt Chocolate + Caramel Bites 35g

Chocolate Heath® Crumble Fudge

Milk Chocolate Malt Balls (7 oz. Bag)

Star Pop

Uncle Butch's Fudge

Walnut Witch

Almond Baby

Walnut Baby

Matcha Baby

Witch Ends Fat Witch Original