For true cheddar connoisseurs, our Extra Sharp Cheddar delivers an intensely rich, crumbly texture and a deeply satisfying, complex tang. Handcrafted with decades of Wisconsin cheesemaking expertise, it's a standout centerpiece for any gourmet cheese board.
Ways to enjoy: As a baked potato topper A slice along classic apple pie A gourmet gr
5.0
5 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
I absolutely love the quality of your cheese! I'm a returning customer and usually order it directly from your company. Hopefully there will be a day when I can buy it from my local supermarket, no matter; delivered, it arrives to me with cold gel packs to keep it perfect all the way to Delaware. I like showing off your cheeses at family get-togethers and always get compliments.
J
James · September 14, 2026
Always a favorite of mine. My all-time favorite was your 8-year-old cheddar but you don't offer that one anymore.
F
Francis · September 14, 2026
My favorite sharp cheddar of all time! Great stuff!