Mill-Aged Extra-Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chocolate Walnut Fudge - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Butter Spread (No Sugar Added) - 10 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Ginger Snaps - 32 Cookies

$6.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

NYS Pure Maple Syrup - Amber Rich - 1 Pint

$32.99

Vegas Food Co-op

4.5 oz Snake Creek Sharp: 2-Year-Old Aged Cheddar

$9.50

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Crisp Topping Mix - 24 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Harvest Pumpkin Dip Mix - 2 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Cinnamon BBQ Sauce - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Buckeyes Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Candy - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chile Con Queso Dip Mix - 2 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Hot Horseradish Mustard - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Blueberry Muffin Mix - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Red Raspberry Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip - 10 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Mini Fig Preserves - 5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Blackened Seasoning - 5.25 oz

Jar of Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard jam on a white background

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Fruits of the Farm Jam - 9 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chocolate Coconut Fudge - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Buttermilk Pancake Mix (All-Natural) - 24 oz

Jar of Fly Creek Beer Can Chicken Rub on a white background

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

"Beer Can" Chicken Rub - 9 oz

(1)

$14.99

B-H Premium Meats

Snake Creek 2yr Aged Sharp Cheddar Cheese.

(3)

$6.29

New York Pure Maple Syrup bottle with label on a white background

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

NYS Pure Maple Syrup - Dark Robust - 1 Pint

$36.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Cinnamon Buttermilk Pancake Mix - 24 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Maple Bacon Jam - 19 oz

$18.99

Elevated sandwich essentials

Breads, pickles, and tinned fish.

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Old English Horseradish Sauce - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Peach Salsa Mild - 15 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion Mustard - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion Steak Sauce - 9.5 oz

Fall baking staples

Flours, spices, apple butter, and streusel toppers.

Farm Store at Sheldon Creek Dairy

Sheldon Creek Dairy - Old Cheddar

$15.00

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Rhubarb-Raspberry Jam - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Champagne Dill Mustard - 8 oz

Three jars of Fly Creek Cider Mill mustard products in a cardboard box with a ribbon.

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Mustard Gift Box - 3 Best Selling Dips

$34.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Tractor Jam - 9 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Cheezy Biscuit Muffin Mix - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

T.O.E. Jam - 9 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Streusel Coffee Cake Mix - 16 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chicken Lickin' Rub - 6.25 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

1856 Bouillabaisse - 24.3 oz

(1)

$17.99

Exclusive offer available

Gardners Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage

17-Year-Old Super-Sharp Cheddar

(225)

$34.00$40.00

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Red Raspberry Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Double Apple Muffin Mix - 16 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Cranberry Bourbon Jalapeno Jam - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Balsamic Sweet Onion Jam - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Salsa Mild - 15 oz

(1)

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Seedless Red Raspberry Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Butter - 8.5 oz

(1)

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip - 10 oz

Back-to-school breakfast

Pancake mixes, yogurt, and seed butters.

Exclusive offer available

Wisconsin Cheese Mart

Cheddar 18 Year Extra Sharp

(5)

$24.00

Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard Chicken Tortilla Soup Mix packaging on a white background

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chicken Tortilla Soup Mix - 5.2 oz

$15.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Bread Mix - 16 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Hot Mulled Cider Spices (for Cider, Wine, Tea) - 8 Bags

$8.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Mini Blueberry Preserves - 5 oz

Flavor of Ohio Gift Baskets

WALNUT CREEK SHARP CHEDDAR

$6.50

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Hot & Sharp German Mustard - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

F.R.O.G. Pond Jam - 9 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Strawberry Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Truffle Mustard - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Mini Red Pepper Jelly - 5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Blueberry Buttermilk Pancake Mix - 24 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Tangy Carolina Mustard BBQ Sauce - 13 oz

Jar of Chili Starter with Fly Creek Cider Mill label on a white background

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chili Starter - 15.5 oz

$12.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Blueberry Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Pumpkin Butter - 9.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Pickled Baby Beets - 16 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Peanut Brittle - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Cinnamon Muffin Mix - 8 oz

14% off

Creamery Creek Farms

Wisconsin 4 Year Aged Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(2)

$12.00$14.00

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Creamy Vidalia® Onion Salad Dressing - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Pub Beer Mustard Dip - 10 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chili Stone Ground Mustard - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Cherry Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Cranberry Salsa Mild - 15 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Strawberry-Rhubarb Preserves - 10.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Mini Honey Mustard Pretzel Dip - 4.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Apple Pie Jam - 10.5 oz

Lisle Livestock & Fresh Market

Old Cheddar White Cheese

CA$20.00

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Smokey Apple Cider BBQ Sauce - 11 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion Summer Tomato Salad Dressing - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Chocolate Fudge - 8 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Honeycrisp Apple Sauce - 25 oz

$14.99

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Artichoke & Spinach Dip Mix - 1.5 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion & Peppercorn Salad Dressing - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion Honey Mustard Salad Dressing - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Vidalia® Onion BBQ Sauce - 12 oz

Fly Creek Cider Mill Online Store

Triple Berry Jam - 9 oz