S

Southern Baked Pie Company

Visit store

Southern Baked Pie Company

4.5 (123)

Buttermilk Pie

Name: Southern Baked Pie Company Buttermilk Pie - Buttermilk Pie
Brand: Southern Baked Pie Company
SKU: 20234718467
Price: 39.95 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.2333 (18 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$39.95

Quantity

One time purchase

$39.95

Subscribe & save

Save 10%

$35.96$39.95

Delivers every week

Color

Black

Quantity

Our namesake custard pie, baked with hints of vanilla and nutmeg, in our signature, all-butter crust. Very similar to a chess pie or crème brulee. It is sweet but not overly sweet. For busy weeknights, everyday entertaining, or a thoughtful...

Reviews

4.2

30 ratings

Great pies delivered right on time!

Cindy · April 16, 2026

Daughter loves this pie. It is delicious!

Pamela · December 6, 2025

I wanted to try this as a possible source for client gifts. My overall recommendation is very low. The filling had a nice taste, but the crust did not. With the high shipping cost, which was more than the price of the pie, it is definitely NOT worth it.

Robin · March 28, 2025