Black Ruffle Skirt w/ Bottoms

Fit is great

Perfect swim skirt

I love this swim skirt/ bottom. It is very flattering, extremely well-constructed, and works with a variety of tops. I usually wear a 1X for bottoms but moved to a 2X based on lime ricki’s size chart and is perfect. I ended up ordering a second one in the azalea big cat print.

Inconsistent sizing

Have the ultra high-waist skirt in another color, and the large is perfect. I ordered the black in a large, and it was too small. I returned it for an XL, and it is way to big. I’m not sure what to do? Keep the big one or try another large in hopes it fits like the other color?