Filled with homemade cider jelly for a unique taste
Classic thumbprint cookie recipe for nostalgic appeal
Available in a box of 12 cookies for sharing or gifting
Versatile treat suitable for holidays or everyday enjoyment
This classic cookie is made even tastier by the old country kitchen trick of filling a thumbprint with something special - in this case, our own famous Cider Jelly - before cooking. The sweetly delicious result has become a favorite in our store and is now available through our catalog. Each box comes with 12 irresistible 2" cookies. A ho
4.5
24 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Nice flavor- not too sweet. Good texture - not too soft nor too hard.
Tong · July 12, 2026
Great cookies !
Love love love these cookies !!
So good . Will definitely buy again !!
D
David · February 27, 2026
THE BEST!!!
I have simply fallen in love with the cider jelly thumbprint cookies from Cold Hollow. My husband is from Vermont and we visited the Cold Hollow Cider Mill last year - it is an amazing place. We usually order these cookies only for special occasions, but I love them so much, we may start to order them more! Incredible quality.