C

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

Visit store

Cold Hollow Cider Mill

4.5 (123)

Cold Hollow - Thumbprint Cookies

Name: Cold Hollow Cider Mill Cold Hollow - Thumbprint Cookies - Cold Hollow - Thumbprint Cookies
Brand: Cold Hollow Cider Mill
SKU: 41962647683131
Price: 10.95 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4.4545 (16 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$10.95

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

This classic cookie is made even tastier by the old country kitchen trick of filling a thumbprint with something special - in this case, our own famous Cider Jelly - before cooking. The sweetly delicious result has become a favorite in our ...

Reviews

4.5

22 ratings

Great cookies !

Love love love these cookies !! So good . Will definitely buy again !!

David · February 27, 2026

THE BEST!!!

I have simply fallen in love with the cider jelly thumbprint cookies from Cold Hollow. My husband is from Vermont and we visited the Cold Hollow Cider Mill last year - it is an amazing place. We usually order these cookies only for special occasions, but I love them so much, we may start to order them more! Incredible quality.

Connie · January 4, 2026

Not McIntosh Apples

I have been searching for original heirloom McIntosh apples. These were close but still a miss. The coloration of peel and meat were perfect but the true McIntosh flavor is missing- not even close. The apples however were good quality and made great apple butter; but they are NOT true McIntosh apples. I emailed them but got no response.

James · October 21, 2025