Folks will drive for miles to get a slice of The Old Mill Restaurant’s legendary Pecan Pie. It’s that good! We’ve been baking and serving our authentic version of this Southern treasure every day for more than 25 years. From the crunchy pecans to the perfect crust, every piece is a slice of holiday heaven.
9” Serves 6-8. Orders that have
4.8
88 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
It arrived more than a week after I ordered it. It was a gift and it was supposed to be sent to my friends house. Even though I entered my friends address on The Mill website and on Shop it still came to my house. It was very hard and dry, couldnt cut through it. Had to break it. I wouldn’t recommend as it is too expensive for these issues. I had to give it a star so the rating would enter, its really a zero star purchase.
B
Bob · August 26, 2026
Pecan Pie
Pie was delicious. A bit difficult to get a knife into it. Still Delicious
C
Customer · January 26, 2026
Burnt?
Pretty disappointed. The pie arrived very burnt, it is not like this when you get it at the restaurant. This pie is too expensive for it not to be perfect.