The Complete Collection brings together all five eye pencils in one curated set: Black, Dark Brown, Chocolate Brown, Champagne Bronze and Steel Gray, plus our custom sharpener.
Your capsule wardrobe of eyeliners, designed to create timeless...
Reviews
5.0
7 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
I am completely blown away by this formula! As a 31-year-old busy mama, eyeliners usually bleed into my smile lines or disappear in the humidity unless I waste time setting them with powder. This liner completely changed the game!!
It’s an ultra-pigmented cream shadow/eyeliner hybrid that is incredibly creamy and easy to work with. I did a 5-hour wear test with zero powder to set it, and it stayed prominent and beautiful all day! Having the high-quality brush right on the end makes it the perfect “One & Done” product when you need to look amazing fast. The industry isn't doing what this brand is doing! Gabi is truly phenomenal and so are these liners! 🥰🫶🏻
M
Morgan · May 29, 2026
I've put away most of my existing eyeliners because they no longer work well with my mature eyes. The Mature eyeliners are really soft and they glide right onto the eyelid. I can even create a cute little "flick" to help lift my eyes so they look more youthful. I'm so glad I bought all 5 of the colors offered!
K
Kimberly · May 19, 2026
I just got all 5 Mature Beauty eyeliners (and a sharpener that looks like my PML). The components are chic, reminding me of YSL and they have that stiffer slant brush on the other end, like YSL. I applied them on the back of my hand last night and after my shower this morning they are still there! I had to use makeup remover to remove them. They apply creamily. The shades are perfect. I'd buy these instead of my beloved YSL because the price point is so much better. Well done Gabi!