Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Cutie Patootie

Products

Products

Cutie Patootie

Reese's PB Cup Squishi

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$9.99

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shopping designed around you.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Quantity

1

Description

Squeeze, squish, and smile with this adorable Reese's Peanut Butter Cup squishy toy. Soft, squishy, and perfectly sized for on-the-go fun, it's ideal for stress relief, sensory play, or collecting. The iconic peanut butter cup design makes ...

Delivery & Returns

Cutie Patootie

4.8 (356)

You might also like

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems ASMR Unicorn

Cutie Patootie

Sticky Squish Gingerbread Man

Cutie Patootie

Sugar Squeezy Glitter SeaShell

Cutie Patootie

Skwishy 4.5” Pet Dogs

Cutie Patootie

Green Light Up Chick

Cutie Patootie

Strawberry Butter Slow Rise Sqiush

Buttercup Lynne Boutique

4.9

(987)

Cutie Patootie

5" Strawberry Dough-Filled Squishy

Cutie Patootie

2.5" Sugar Squeezy Fruit - Assorted

Cutie Patootie

3.5" Bead-Filled Squishy Bun

Cutie Patootie

13" Giant Jumbo Squishy Banana

Cutie Patootie

2" Glitter Squeez Cube

Cutie Patootie

Suction Kupz

Cutie Patootie

Assorted Tile Shufflers

Cutie Patootie

Crystal Squeezy

Cutie Patootie

5" Squeezy Sugar Crab

Cutie Patootie

Goofy Bun Squishy

Cutie Patootie

Honeybee Fusion Ball

Caldwell Gifts

Caldwell Gifts

Caldwell Gifts

4.9

(314)

Cutie Patootie

Boba Buddiez

Cutie Patootie

Maltose Octopus Squishy

Cutie Patootie

3 Babies - Mega Mystery Dumplin

Cutie Patootie

Squeezy Crystal Ball

Cutie Patootie

3.25" Squish And Stretch Surprise Dumplings

Cutie Patootie

Mini Sugar Squeezy Dumplings

Cutie Patootie

Honeycrisp Apple Slime

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Glitter Sugar Cube - Assorted

Comfrt

Comfrt

Comfrt

4.8

(460.6K)

Frost

Frost

Walnut / F / M

Bone / F

Cement / F / M

Livi Littles

Best-Loved Bible Stories Lift-a-Flap Board Book

(1)

Cutie Patootie

Plane Knit Rattle

Livi Littles

Livi Littles

5

(245)

Cutie Patootie

5" Strawberry Slow Rise Butter

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Diamond

(1)

Cutie Patootie

Christmas Qube - Assorted

(2)

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Unicorn

Cutie Patootie

Sugarsqueez Ball

Cutie Patootie

CandyTide Crystal Pig Stress Toy - Assorted

Cutie Patootie

The Big Squij Jumbo Marshmallow - CANNOT BE SHIPPED

Cutie Patootie

Air Freshener

Alo Yoga

4.7

(469K)

Cutie Patootie

Perrie Penguin Soft

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Shapes - Assorted

Cutie Patootie

2" Maltose Sugar Cheese Squishy

Caldwell Gifts

Sweetie Shake Plus™ - Teething + Rattle Toy: Croissant

Cutie Patootie

Stripe Knit Flutter Bubble Romper

Cutie Patootie

4" Squeezy Sugar Sea Turtle

The Refinery

The Refinery

4.8

(173)

Cutie Patootie

2.5" Squeezy Sugar Cupcake

Cutie Patootie

5" Assorted Rainbow Slow Rise Butter

Cutie Patootie

Easter Tie Dye Egg Lollipop

Cutie Patootie

5” Dough Filled Butter Squishy

Cutie Patootie

Stretchy Banana

Cutie Patootie

Mystery Mini Dumplinz

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Squish Fruit Basket

Cutie Patootie

Outta This World Metallic Slime

Kay's & Grace DTF Transfer

4.9

(27)

Cutie Patootie

3.25" Squish And Stretch Metallic Surprise Dumplings

Cutie Patootie

Heritage Stitches Riley Bubble

Caldwell Gifts

Brown Dog Warmies Junior

Cutie Patootie

Squeeze Pop Assorted Flavor Tube

Cutie Patootie

Candy Corn Slow Rise Stress Toy

Cutie Patootie

Sugar Cat Squishies

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Scented Candy Cat Squishy

Cutie Patootie

Soft Peanut Squishy Toy

(1)

Owl and Goose Gifts

Owl and Goose Gifts

4.9

(9.8K)

Cutie Patootie

Assorted Slushie Bear Squishy

Cutie Patootie

Surprise Squishy Dumpling babies

Cutie Patootie

2.5" Mini Mystery Glitter Dumpling

Cutie Patootie

3.5" Mystery Tie Dye/Glitter Dumpling

Cutie Patootie

Tilly Giraffe Soft Toy

Cutie Patootie

Moldable Vaseline Squishy Butter

Cutie Patootie

FLUFFMELLIES Cute Dog

Cutie Patootie

Glitter Slime

Mollie’s Nest

Mollie’s Nest

5

(25)

Cutie Patootie

8" Toy Story Squishmallows

Cutie Patootie

Sugar Jack- O'Lantern Ball

Cutie Patootie

Fruity Banana Maltose Squishy

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems ASMR Square

(1)

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Axolotl

Cutie Patootie

Jumbo Squishy Pumpkin CANNOT BE SHIPPED

Cutie Patootie

Squishy Axolotl w/babies

Cutie Patootie

9" Assorted Rainbow Slow Rise Butter

Smallwoods

4.7

(103.2K)

Cutie Patootie

Sugar Squeezy Butterfly

Cutie Patootie

Sugar Swaps Mini Animal Pals

Cutie Patootie

Dough Dough Squish Popsicle - Assorted

Cutie Patootie

Scrunchems Sugar Squish Drop

Cutie Patootie

Rhyme Stripe Boxer Brief

Cutie Patootie

Sleepy Octopus - Bedtime Story from the Ocean Tonie

Delta T Boutique

Mini Boar Tortoise Hairbrush By Teleties