Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Millie's Magnets

Products

Millie's Magnets

Mystery $5 pens

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$5.00

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

You might also like

Hidden Gems

Mystery Reveal Pens

53% off

LUVIA STORE

5 Pen Mystery Box

(4)

Graceful Goods

Mystery Pen

(1)

Exclusive deal available

Chance & Charms Mystery Shop

🖊️ Pen Mystery Boxes 🖊️ | 6 Surprise Items + Hidden Charm Bonuses

(9)

What's In the Scoop

Mystery Pen Boxes

75% off

Joykawaii

Lovely girl Mystery Pen

Cosmic Cove Creations

Mystery Doorable Pen

Mystery Pen Packs - 3 Pack

Razertip Industries Ltd

Mystery Pen Packs - 3 Pack

(1)

Squish & Scribble

Mystery Pen Bags

(1)

66% off

By Lucy Designs

Pen mystery grab bag

Birds & Bears Boutique

Custom Made Black Ink Pens

(54)

Cratejoy

Writing Mystery

(1)

Funny Pen Mystery Bag – Opened Live

Sparkle DIY Shop

Funny Pen Mystery Bag – Opened Live

Cookie Crumbles Mystery Shop

Pen Blind Boxes

(3)

PEACOCK GLAMOUR

Mystery Character Pen

Little Finds by Katy K

Pen Mystery Box — 5 pcs

(45)

818 Serendipity Surprise

Mystery Pens

estelle.crystals

Mystery Monster Pens (Read Description)

Merlybell

Pretty Pen Mix Mystery Bag – Cute & Aesthetic Surprise Pens

LANEST STORE

Pen Mystery Box

(7)

Five silhouettes of pens or pencils against a grey background.

CLOTH & PAPER

Surprise Pen Pack

(144)

Rosie's Glam Boutique

Mystery pen boxes

(1)

Millie's Magnets

Dental squad

Mama Bear's Southern Creations

MBSC-mystery beaded pens

Solara & Bundles

Pens & Highlighters Mystery Box✨

(5)

Shea Scoops

Mystery Pen Boxes

41% off

GoGo Designs

N8. Color Match Mystery Pen Game – 30+ Pens, Markers & Highlighters

50% off

Mama Bear Creations

5 pack PreMade 9.24.26

LANEST STORE

🔑 Secret Key Pens

(1)

Murder mystery party investigation pens for mystery parties.

Exclusive deal available

My Mystery Party

Set of 10 CSI Mystery Investigation Pens | Mystery Party Prop

Rosia

Mystery Pen

33% off

Cute Stickers Only

Pens Mystery Grab Bags

(4)

Millie's Magnets

RN pumpkin

Scribble & Sparkles Mystery Scoops

5 Stationery

(10)

50% off

Just Follow Your Art

Mystery Pen Pack

Cutie Crafts and Scoops

Surprise bag of 3 pens

PEACOCK GLAMOUR

Hello Kitty Pens - Mystery

Darling Mystery Shop

Mystery Pen Bags

(15)

Darling Mystery Shop

Mystery Pen Bags

(2)

Mystery Product for the Month - October - 2026 - Pen Boutique Ltd

47% off

Pen Boutique Ltd

Mystery Product for the Month - October - 2026

(653)

Exclusive deal available

LEXI STORES

Writing Tools Mystery Box - 12 pcs

(1)

Millie's Magnets

CNA

(1)

Bookish Brews Nook

Mystery Pen Scoops

(5)

Cheeky Charms

🖊️ Mystery Beaded Pen Blind Pulls

(4)

Bakers Mystery Scoops & Bundles

Handmade Beaded Pen

(2)

Chesapeake Mystery Scoops

Mystery Pens

Emilyscustomcreations

Mystery game: pen pulls

Millie's Magnets

Behavior analyst

Wonder Pens

Mystery Pen Surprise - Pack of 6

(10)

45% off

Mama Bear Creations

Mystery Wristlet + 2 Pens

Darling Mystery Shop

Mystery Pen Bags

(9)

Darling Mystery Shop

Mystery Pen Bags

(7)

Jaliyah.Kreationz

Mystery Pen Trio :3 Random Pens

(7)

SparkleSociety

Mystery Beaded Pens

(1)

Mama Bear's Southern Creations

Sassy Server-mystery beaded pens

Jersey Girls Scoop Shop LLC

6 Christmas Mystery Pen Boxes

(2)

Millie's Magnets

ICU goose

Michelle Creates @ Bella Acres LLC

Mystery Pen Blind Boxes (6 boxes)

(3)

Scribble & Sparkles Mystery Scoops

Mystery DIY pen kit

(22)

Victorian McGee’s Character Pens 5x Random Pens (Our Choice) pen

Mysterious

Victorian McGee's Character Pens

(55)

Millie's Magnets

Sea shell

(1)

Meg’s Mystery Mix

Meg's Mystery Pen Bags

(2)

Millie's Magnets

ORTHO crew

Spine & Glow Co.

Mystery Pen Game

(1)

Darling Mystery Shop

Mystery Pen Bags

(1)

Little Finds by Katy K

Writing Tools Mystery Box — 12 pcs

(6)

Exclusive deal available

ST Designs Store

Beaded Mystery Pen

(12)

Bayou Books and Beans

🌈🖊️ MYSTERY COLOR CHANGING PEN! 🖊️🌈

Hidden Gems

DIY Mystery Reveal Beadable Pens Kit

Unifindit

Pens, Pencils & Highlighters Mystery Box

(43)

83% off

Joykawaii

Marie Cat Mystery Pen

Millie's Magnets

PARA

Jersey Girls Scoop Shop LLC

12 Christmas Mystery Pen Boxes

(1)

ALEXEN DREAM STORE LLC

Pens & Highlighters Mystery Box

(55)

43% off

Life of Colour

Pens Mystery Box

(39)

Honey Lou Collective

The Pens Mystery 5 Pack

(2)

Exclusive deal available

LEXI STORES

Pen Mystery Box - 5 pcs

(4)

My little corner of the world!

Mystery Bags- Pens (minimum of 10)

(2)

Midlands Vinyl

JESS'S MYSTERY PENS

(1)

PoshGiftz

Posh Pen Mystery Boxes - 5 boxes

(3)

Enchanted String

Pen Mystery Box

(4)

Journal Magic

Mystery Boujee Pen

Mystery bundle bliss

💜 The Mystery Pen Bag Collection – 10 Bags, 10 Pens & Surprise Wins

(6)

Exclusive deal available

Hmbb

Mystery Pen 🖊️

Learning Express Toys & Gifts - Huntsville AL

Mighty Monster Pens

Breska's Mystery Bundles

Mystery Ink Boxes

(25)

13% off

Break Room Boutique

Mystery Coffee Click Pen

Allie Reese Cute Things

[SURPRISE SET - 5 PIECES] B/C Grade Pens SURPRISE SET

(6)

Bless.Notes

Pen Mystery Box

(27)

Maze Ballpoint Pens 5/10-Pack | Fun Puzzle Game Writing Pen Novelty Ballpoint Pen QXL

Exclusive deal available

QXL

Maze Ballpoint Pens 5/10-Pack | Fun Puzzle Game Writing Pen