Rich and creamy banana cream filling on a layer of dark chocolate ganache, topped with fresh whipped cream, more chocolate and banana chips, all in a graham crust.
Ingredients
Banana
Chocolate
Cream
Eggs
Vanilla
Bananas, Chocolate, Milk, Cream, Flour, Butter, Graham Crumbs, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Eggs, Cornstarch, Vanilla, Icing Suga
4.7
32 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Delicious pie but does not store well
Ordered the chunky monkey for pickup on a Friday as I was having guests over on Saturday. I cut a slice on Friday night and found the next day that there was a pool of liquid at the bottom of the pan, likely from the banana cream, that made the bottom crust soggy and mushy. Unfortunate as it did not taste as great the next day (the crust was great on Friday but not on Saturday). I'd only recommend this pie if you are serving it on the same day as pickup.
H
Hannah · June 22, 2026
Delicious!
The banana-chocolate flavour combo was very well-balanced and is just the right amount of sweet. I would definitely get this pie again!
A
Angeli · March 6, 2026
The monkey was a bit chunky
One of my wife’s favourite ice cream flavour is B&Js Chunky Monkey which is no longer available in Canada, so I was unsure what to expect when we ordered the Chunky Monkey pie for my wife’s birthday. I was happy to discover the pie was very good and not overly sweet and most importantly the birthday girl enjoyed it.
