Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Banner's Hallmark

Products

Products

Banner's Hallmark

Rainbow Butter Squishy

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$10.99

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shopping designed around you.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Quantity

1

Description

The Rainbow Butter Squishy is a vibrant, slow-rising fidget toy designed to resemble a whimsical stick of butter featuring a multi-colored, tie-dye aesthetic. Unlike traditional single-color butter toys, this version blends bright hues like...

Delivery & Returns

Banner's Hallmark

4.9 (869)

You might also like

Banner's Hallmark

Cheese Vent Toys

(1)

Banner's Hallmark

Glitter Squishy Dumplings-Large

Banner's Hallmark

Mini Maltose Squishy Mystery Buns

Owl and Goose Gifts

Aurora Plush 8 Inch Peanuts Blue Winter Scarf Snoopy Holiday Plush Toy

Banner's Hallmark

Pink And Orange Pom-Pom Gift Bow, 5.5"

The Office wall decor with Dwight Schrute quote on blinds and hidden illustration revealed by turning a back dial.

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Dwight Schrute Behind Blinds Wall Decor

Prickly Pear TX

Squishy RAINBOW Butter Toy

(1)

Banner's Hallmark

Geegee Pig Pajamas Lullabies Blind Box

Banner's Hallmark

Keep It Reel Mug, 16 oz.

Silver-plated bracelet with heart charm on a 'Will You Be My Bridesmaid?' message card by Katie Loxton.

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

A Little Will You Be My Bridesmaid Bracelet

Jelly Belly Unicorn Mix featuring flavors like Bubble Gum and Birthday Cake in a magical grab & go bag.

Banner's Hallmark

Unicorn Mix Jelly Beans Grab & Go Bag 3.5 oz

American Carnival Mart

Squish Rainbow Butter 5.25" (EACH)

Banner's Hallmark

Excited for Eggs Bunny Plush With Sound and Motion

Brown teddy bear with black eyes and stitched nose and smile. It has short, floppy ears and wears a red ribbon tied

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Ruff Ruff - Palm Pals

Banner's Hallmark

Sonic The Hedgehog™ Sonic With Chaos Emerald Ornament

Banner's Hallmark

Squeeze Strawberry

(1)

24% off

My Sensory Space

Slow Rising Rainbow Butter Stick Squishy Giant 22cm

Banner's Hallmark

Crazy Slimy - Good as Gold 6 7

(1)

Hallmark itty bittys® Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Snoopy Plush

Steve's Hallmark

Hallmark itty bittys® Peanuts® 75th Anniversary Snoopy Plush

Banner's Hallmark

Geegee Pig Countdown to Wishes Blind Box

Hallmark The Office blue metal letter holder with Dunder Mifflin and Michael Scott Paper Company logos.

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Dunder Mifflin Letter Holder

Accents Home & Gifts

Rainbow Butter Squishy

Banner's Hallmark

Upset Duck Born This Way Blind Box

Banner's Hallmark

Ducks of Kindness Charm

A 12 oz glass jar of whipped honey with chocolate, made with wildflower honey and fair-trade cocoa powder.

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Whipped Honey with Chocolate

Green Beans Toys

Squeezy Bead Animal Ball (ONE)

Cutie Patootie

Crystal Squeezy

Teal Hallmark trinket tray with scalloped edge and message “It’s not what you do in life, it’s how good you look doing it.”

Banner's Hallmark

How Good You Look Funny Trinket Tray

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Kinsley Kisses Heart - Palm Pals - 5"

Banner's Hallmark

Silver & Pearl Dangle Earrings

Owl and Goose Gifts

Owl and Goose Gifts

4.9

(9.8K)

23% off

My Sensory Space

Slow Rising Rainbow Butter Stick Squishy 13cm

(23)

Banner's Hallmark

Kimmon 7" Spring New Growth Blind Box

Banner's Hallmark

Patriot Eagle - Palm Pals - 5"

Banner's Hallmark

Kimmon Warm Moment Series 7" Blind Box

Cranberry and orange peel scented 2-wick candle in glass jar with cranberry and orange illustrations and cork lid

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Cranberry and Orange Peel Scented 2-Wick Jar Candle, 14.5

Banner's Hallmark

Kimmon 7" You're The Protagonist Series Blind Box

Banner's Hallmark

Lil' Cupcake

Disney Winnie the Pooh ceramic honey pot with wooden honey wand, holds 6.75 oz, hand wash only.

Banner's Hallmark

Disney Winnie The Pooh Ceramic Honey Pot with Wand

Goldtone ballpoint pen with a fluffy pom topper, perfect for adding flair to school, work, or journaling tasks.

Banner's Hallmark

Crush Noted Pom Pen

Close-up of Jelly Belly sour jelly beans with tangy fruit flavor coating.

Banner's Hallmark

Sours Jelly Beans Grab & Go Bag 3.5 oz

Fruit Butter squishy fidget toy in assorted colours for stress relief, sensory play and improved focus

30% off

Collectables

Fruit Butter Squishy Fidget Toy – Assorted Colours

Blue and green plush tugboat toy with pull-string lifebuoy ring and soft fabric, designed for toddlers.

Banner's Hallmark

Zip-Along Tugboat Plush Toy

Banner's Hallmark

Americana Star - Palm Pals - 5"

Banner's Hallmark

Gift Bag Square X-Small - Schools Out

Banner's Hallmark

Pink Squishy Butter Toy

Owl and Goose Gifts

Slow Rise Squishy Butter RAINBOW 5 Inch Sensory Toy

(3)

Banner's Hallmark

Upset Duck Act Cute Blind Box

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Cottontail Bunny - Party Sized - Palm Pals - 13"

Coral pink fleece blanket with white big sis lettering, soft polyester, perfect gift for new big sister.

Banner's Hallmark

Big Sis Fleece Blanket, 50x60

Gray ceramic mug with “Kevin’s Famous Chili” printed in bold black letters and brown glaze accents

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Kevin's Famous Chili Ceramic Mug, 16 oz

Smiling plush hamburger toy with sesame seed bun, lettuce, tomato, cheese layers, dances and plays a parody of 'Girls Just Wanna Have Fun.

Banner's Hallmark

Hamburger Plush With Sound and Motion, 10"

Banner's Hallmark

Party Sized - Limited Edition America B'Day Cake - Palm Pals - 8"

Banner's Hallmark

The Peanuts® Gang Off To The Races! Musical Ornament With Motion

Ceramic 15 oz mug with quotes and icons from The Office and a musical coaster that plays the theme song.

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Musical Mug, 15 oz.

12% off

Showcase USA - Home Of The Hottest Trends

Rainbow Butter Foam Slow-Rise Squishy 5.5" Fidget Toy (1pc)

11% off

Something Different Shopping

Butter Squishy-Slow Rising w/ cardboard tray

Hallmark Minecraft pig plush toy with soft pink fur, pixelated design, and movable legs that activate sound and motion.

Banner's Hallmark

Minecraft Pig Plush With Sound and Motion

Banner's Hallmark

National Lampoon'S Christmas Vacation™ Clark Griswold Ornament With Sound

Hallmark The Peanuts® Gang Lucy's All Tangled Up! Ornament

Steve's Hallmark

Hallmark The Peanuts® Gang Lucy's All Tangled Up! Ornament

Banner's Hallmark

Squishy Mystery Buns-Large

littlewhimsy

Butter Squishy RAINBOW

Banner's Hallmark

Nommi 8" Plush Interesting Fruits Blind Box

Banner's Hallmark

Nommi 8.75" Plush Amaryllis Sweetheart Blind Box

Black tape dispenser styled like a desk from The Office with Parkour scene silhouette and Dundie Award

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Parkour Tape Dispenser With Sound

A set of four white resin coasters with blue and yellow birds perched on leafy branches in vibrant colors

55% off

Banner's Hallmark

Colorful Bird Branch Coaster (Set of 4)

Trolls Band Together medium gift bag featuring Poppy and Viva with star accents on a pink and blue ombré background, 9.6

Banner's Hallmark

Trolls Band Together Medium Gift Bag, 9.6"

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Cottontail Bunny - Party Sized - Palm Pals - 8"

Banner's Hallmark

Nostalgic Houses And Shops Arts And Crafts Bungalow Ornament

tissue paper is typically used to wrap gifts for celebratory occasions, such as graduations, birthdays, or weddings

Banner's Hallmark

Gold Congrats Graduation Tissue Paper, 6 sheets

Learning Express Toys & Gifts / Neon Elephant

Rainbow Butter Squishy

Toy with a smiling face in a yellow container, featuring a 'Jublo' label on a white background.

38% off

Hamrick's Shop

Squishy Dumpling

(1)

Banner's Hallmark

Darcy Goldendoodle

Hallmark set of 12 jumbo paper clips with colorful messages and black-and-white geometric designs for fun organization.

Banner's Hallmark

Cute and Colorful Assorted Jumbo Paper Clips, Set of 12

25% off

Steve's Hallmark

Hallmark Trick or Treat! Halloween Press-and-Play Sound Book

Banner's Hallmark

Squeeze Donut Toy

Banner's Hallmark

Rainbow Squishy Mystery Buns

Banner's Hallmark

America B'Day Cake - Palm Pals - 5"

Banner's Hallmark

Small Hanging Two-Toned Bird

Yellow desk calendar with a stapler inside it. The date "24" and "MAR" are printed on the calendar. Text on the calendar says "PERPETUAL CALENDAR". pen_spark tune share more_vert

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

The Office Stapler in Gelatin Perpetual Calendar

Gold wire Harry Potter letter holder with Deathly Hallows design

Banner's Hallmark

Harry Potter Deathly Hallows Letter Holder

Banner's Hallmark

Pitenaught Into Neverland Blind Box

Growing Tree Toys

Aurora® Palm Pals™ Finnigan Leprechaun Hat™ 5"

A set of four off-white coasters, each with a different sun design and cheerful quote like "You Are My Sunshine".

55% off

Banner's Hallmark

Sunshine Coasters - (Set of 4)

Jellyroos Plush Toy- Guac Avocado

Green Beans Toys

Jellyroos Plush Squeezy Bead Avocado

Exclusive offer available

S. Feldman Housewares

Squishy Butter Fidget Toy

Soft gray baby elephant stuffed animal with floppy ears and trunk, made of plush fabric, 7.75 inches tall.

Banner's Hallmark

Baby Elephant Stuffed Animal, 7.75"

Finnigan Palm Pals plush leprechaun hat with green body, golden belt buckle, and cheerful smile—perfect for St. Patrick’s

50% off

Banner's Hallmark

Finnigan Leprechaun Hat - Palm Pals

Banner's Hallmark

Baseball Star 2026 Ornament

Rainbow Jumbo Butter Squishy Fidget Toy 22cm with colourful swirl design

33% off

Collectables

Rainbow Jumbo Butter (22cm) Squishy Fidget Toy