Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Olive Lane Oils

Products

Products

Olive Lane Oils

"Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$8.95

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shop is the next step on our mission to make commerce better for everyone.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Purchase at Olive Lane Oils

Description

Pretty Boy is unabashedly sharp with a propensity for the gilded and grandiose. Aged to perfection, this charming cheddar is opulent with copious amounts of character as expected from a Wisconsin-made fella. Have a hunk with cured salami an...

Delivery & Returns

Visit Olive Lane Oils for full shipping details

Shipping calculated at checkout

Olive Lane Oils

5 (29)

You might also like

Olive Lane Oils

8-Year-Aged Cheddar

Package of six gourmet Wisconsin string cheese sticks.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

String Cheese

(200)

Block of Pretty Boy sharp artisan Wisconsin cheddar next to playing cards and cheese slices.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

"Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

(339)

Eatin-Good

Cheese Brothers Classic Gouda

Olive Lane Oils

Erbe Italiane di Lusso

Package of Rhapsody parmesan and cheddar cheese surrounded by nuts, honey, and cheese cubes.

15% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Rhapsody

(956)

Hill Valley Dairy

Sharp Cheddar

Fashion Flare Boutique

Classic Gouda

Olive Lane Oils

Underwater Wonders Kid’s Apron

Container of port wine cheese spread with crackers and glass of wine.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Port Wine Cheese Spread

(107)

Olive Lane Oils

Fratello - Italian Style Cheese

Cheers in a Box

Cheese Brother's Rhapsody Reserve

Olive Lane Oils

Beer Cheddar Cheese Spread

(1)

Olive Lane Oils

Silicone Spatula (Black) with Olive Wood Handle - 12"

Cheese Brothers canvas gouda cheese on art easel with charcuterie board in an art space.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Classic Gouda

(170)

Fashion Flare Boutique

Smoked Gouda

Fashion Flare Boutique

"Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

Findlay Market Shopping App

Cheddar - Best Sharp - Aged Wisconsin Cheddar

Taco Tuesday favorites

Taco Tuesday favorites

Tortillas, slaws, and salsas.

Beer Cheddar Cheese Spread by Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Weeks Honey Farm

Beer Cheddar Cheese Spread

Fashion Flare Boutique

Smoked Provolone

Olive Lane Oils

Fusilli Corti in D&G Packaging by Pastificio Di Martino

The Bottle Shop

Cheese Brothers - 8-Year-Aged Cheddar

Package of Cheese Brothers Classic Cheese Curds on a wooden surface

The Attic Door/Bella Vita

Cheese Curds

Sweets and Geeks

4.7

(2.8K)

Candy Cigarettes - Sweets and Geeks

Candy Cigarettes - Sweets and Geeks

Vanilla Caramel Cow Tales - Sweets and Geeks

Olive Lane Oils

Oil and Vinegar Dipping Dish

9% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Creamy Gruyere

(8)

Inspire Farms

Cheese Brothers - Dill Havarti

Olive Lane Oils

Sweet Pickled Garlic Cloves

Cheese Brothers, Inc. Aged Cheese 8-Year-Aged Cheddar

15% off

My American Goods

8-Year-Aged Cheddar

(1)

The Bottle Shop

Cheese!

Sharp Cheddar - Brennans Market

Brennans Market

Sharp Cheddar

(2)

Fashion Flare Boutique

8-Year-Aged Cheddar

Full Circle Sustainability

Cheese - Sharp Cheddar

The Farmhouse Meats & Cheese

Sharp Cheddar

Cold Creek Nurseries

Horseradish Cheddar "Precious Cargo" - Cheese Brothers (6 oz.)

50% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

19-Year-Aged Cheddar

(34)

Olive Lane Oils

Buzzin' Hot Honey

Package of Fratello asiago and parmesan cheese blend on a black slate next to tomatoes and a glass of red wine.

15% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Fratello

(272)

Hosting chips and dip night

Hosting chips and dip night

Herby dips, scoop chips, and kettle classics.

Eatin-Good

Cheese Brothers 8-Year Aged Cheddar Snack Sticks (30-Pack)

15% off

Eatin-Good

Cheese Brothers Smoked Gouda

wholesomenova

Cheese Cheddar Sharp

(1)

Maple Leaf Cheese Store

Cheddar, Sharp (Aged 1 year)

Inspire Farms

Cheese Brothers - "Fields Forever" Green Onion Cheddar

Di Bruno Bros.

Cooper Sharp White American

(4)

The Barn at Locke Vineyards

8-Year-Aged Cheddar

15% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

"Fields Forever" Green Onion Cheddar

(361)

Olive Lane Oils

T-duo Peeler Polymer Handle

Sharp Cheddar Cheese - Nadler's Meats

Nadler's Meats

Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Container of beer cheese spread with crackers and glass of beer.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Beer Cheddar Cheese Spread

(245)

Package of 15-year aged Wisconsin white cheddar.

38% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

15-Year-Aged Cheddar

(359)

Cheese Brothers, Inc. Cheese Spreads Onion and Chive Cheese Spread

My American Goods

Onion and Chive Cheese Spread

Westmeadow Mercantile LLC

CHEDDAR, SHARP - 8oz

(1)

15% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

"Precious Cargo" Horseradish Cheddar

(259)

Eatin-Good

Cheese Brothers "Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

Instant noodle upgrades

Instant noodle upgrades

Noodles, chili crisp, and broth boosters.

Bella The Corner Gourmet

Cheese Brothers - "Pretty Boy" Sharp Cheddar

Package of 8-Year aged Wisconsin white cheddar.

15% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

8-Year-Aged Cheddar

(505)

10% off

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Sharp & Flavorful Cheese Box (8 Cheeses)

(192)

Package of artisan smoked provolone next to microphone, champagne, and disco balls.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Smoked Provolone

(200)

Cheese Brothers, Inc. Smoked Mozzarella

My American Goods

Smoked Mozzarella

Package of Cinderblock gourmet smoked Wisconsin cheddar next to burnt matches and cheese house.

Cheese Brothers, Inc.

Smoked Cheddar

(321)

Fashion Flare Boutique

Dill Havarti

Di Bruno Bros.

Sharp Cheddar

(5)

Inspire Farms

Cheese Brothers Cheese Curds

Fashion Flare Boutique

Golden Baked Bliss Cheese

Olive Lane Oils

Adelheid Alpine-Style Cheese

Olive Lane Oils

Stainless Steel Finger Guards - Set of 2