Number 5 Tavern Mustard

Name: blackwatermustardco.com Number 5 Tavern Mustard - Number 5 Tavern Mustard
Brand: blackwatermustardco.com
SKU: 17600697990
Price: 8.5 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 5 (1 reviews)

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$8.50

Quantity

Color

Black

Quantity

Description

The house mustard of the Number 5 Tavern in Hopkinton, N.H.—stone-ground, medium heat, rich flavor. Enjoy the tavern tradition at home!

Reviews

5.0

2 ratings

Loved both mustards. I ordered the small ones by mistake. My bad. Thanks.

R · October 15, 2025

Delivery & Returns

blackwatermustardco.com

5 (17)

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Blackwater Mustard Co. Everyday Café & Pub Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Everyday Cafe & Pub Mustard

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

A J Cybulski's Polish Mustard

(1)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Tuckerman Pale Ale Mustard

(1)

$8.50

Mac's Maple

Mustard

$7.50

The View Cafe & Gifts

Horseradish Mustard

$8.50

Atlantic Brewing Company

Real Ale Mustard

$6.99

Farmhouse Five

Sun Valley Mustard

(1)

$5.99

Mac's Maple

NH Maple Syrup Glass Bottle

$13.00

Great Alaskan Bowl Company

Moosetard Mustards

(1)

$12.50

Tasmanian Gourmet Online

Tasman's Harvest Hot English Mustard

(1)

$7.00

Cozy Cottage

Pub Mustard - 10oz

(1)

$17.99

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 350°F/177°C

$17.62

The Rustic Market

Traditional Pub Style Mustard

(1)

$8.50

Blackwater Mustard Co. Headwall ALT Brown Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Tuckerman Headwall Alt Brown Ale Mustard

(1)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Chocolate Stout Mustard

(1)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Cranberry Mustard

$8.50

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 250°F/121°C

$17.62

National Mustard Museum

Stonewall Kitchen Horseradish Mustard

$8.75

Lehman's

Artisan Mustards

$11.99

Rustic Interiors LLC

Spicy Honey Mustard

$10.00

Mac's Maple

2% Milk

$3.40

Sweet treats

Candy, cookies, and brownie bites.

Cottonwood Company

Bourbon Molasses Mustard

$9.95

92% off

Key West Spice

Hot Mustard, 5 oz.

$12.00$144.00

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 340°F/171°C

$17.62

Taco Tuesday favorites

Tortillas, slaws, and salsas.

blackwatermustardco.com

Apple Cider Mustard

$8.50

Blackwater Mustard Co. 6288 Stout Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Tuckerman 6288 Stout Mustard

(1)

$8.50

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F/71°C Wide

$17.16

ShopAtDean

Authentic Stadium Mustard 105 oz

(1)

$9.65

The Made in Stroud Shop

Kitchen Garden Foods Tewksbury mustard 175g

(1)

$7.00

HoneycupMustard

_ Multi Pack _ Stone Ground Mustard

(1)

$40.99

Paper Thermometer

3-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F 170°F 180°F

$16.43

National Mustard Museum

Ringhand's Beer Mustard

(2)

$6.95

Country Mercantile

Stonewall Kitchen - Horseradish Mustard

$8.97

10% off

Healthy Heart Market

LocalFolks Foods Stoneground Xxpress Mustard 8oz.

(4)

$4.49$4.99

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F/71°C

$17.62

blackwatermustardco.com

Pope Poupon

$8.50

Blackwater Mustard Co. Smoked Jalapeño Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Georgia's Northside Smoked Jalapeno

(1)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Maple Mustard

(1)

$8.50

Paper Thermometer

Dishwasher Rinse Temp THERMOLABEL® 180°F/82°C

$17.16

Instant noodle upgrades

Noodles, chili crisp, and broth boosters.

National Mustard Museum

Terrapin Ridge Smokey Maple Bacon Mustard

(1)

$8.95

Mac's Maple

Smoked Cheese Bites

$3.50

Paper Thermometer

5-Temp THERMOLABEL® Classic 140-180°F

$19.09

National Mustard Museum

Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Honey Mustard

(1)

$8.75

POQUOSON GIFTS

Bourbon Molasses Mustard

$9.95

National Mustard Museum

Stonewall Kitchen Bourbon Molasses Mustard

$8.75

Harvest Gourmet

Garlic Mustard

(1)

$10.95

blackwatermustardco.com

Hot and Sweet

(3)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Garlic Mustard

$8.50

Blackwater Mustard Co. Hot and Sweet Mug O’ Mustard pint jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

MUG-O-MUSTARD 16 oz

(2)

$16.00

Paper Thermometer

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 165°F/73.9°C

$17.62

20% off

Raddell's Sausage

Stadium Mustard

$7.99$9.99

Scottish Gourmet USA

Galloway Whole Grain Mustard

(1)

$15.00

Mac's Maple

Pure NH Maple Sugar Resealable Bag

(1)

$17.00

Thompsontown Maple

Maple Mustard

$7.33

Spoiled Rotten

Spicy Honey Mustard

$8.49

The Collective Co.

10 oz. Pub Mustard

$12.00

Mac's Maple

Maple Kettle Corn

(2)

$2.50

Bottle of Brewhouse Sauces Redstone Crema Harissa Mustard with a hot dog on a bun being drizzled with the sauce.

Old Town Spice Shop

Redstone Creek Harissa Mustard

$8.00

Blackwater Mustard Co. Dilly Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Jilly's Dilly Mustard

(1)

$8.50

lackwater Mustard Co. Smoked Red Ale Mustard jar on white background.

blackwatermustardco.com

Simply Red Ale Mustard

(2)

$8.50

blackwatermustardco.com

Big Pete's BBQ Sauce

$6.50

TEMECULA Old Town Spice & Tea Merchants

Mustard - Powder

$2.89

Spoiled Rotten

Horseradish Mustard

$8.49

The Rustic Market

Spicy Honey Mustard

$8.50

Mac's Maple

Doughnuts- (Boxes of 6) WEEKENDS ONLY

$10.50

Perfect Settings

Truffle Mustard

$10.00

Spoiled Rotten

Traditional Pub Style Mustard

$8.49

Brown & Hopkins Country Store

Stonewall Kitchen Mustard

$8.50

Mac's Maple

Skim Milk

$3.40

NashvilleSpiceCompany

Sierra Nevada Stout & Stone Ground Mustard

$8.50

Number 5 Tavern Mustard

Reviews

Delivery & Returns

blackwatermustardco.com

You might also like

Everyday Cafe & Pub Mustard

A J Cybulski's Polish Mustard

Tuckerman Pale Ale Mustard

Mustard

Horseradish Mustard

Real Ale Mustard

Sun Valley Mustard

NH Maple Syrup Glass Bottle

Moosetard Mustards

Tasman's Harvest Hot English Mustard

Pub Mustard - 10oz

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 350°F/177°C

Traditional Pub Style Mustard

Tuckerman Headwall Alt Brown Ale Mustard

Chocolate Stout Mustard

Cranberry Mustard

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 250°F/121°C

Stonewall Kitchen Horseradish Mustard

Artisan Mustards

Spicy Honey Mustard

2% Milk

Bourbon Molasses Mustard

Hot Mustard, 5 oz.

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 340°F/171°C

Apple Cider Mustard

Tuckerman 6288 Stout Mustard

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F/71°C Wide

Authentic Stadium Mustard 105 oz

Kitchen Garden Foods Tewksbury mustard 175g

_ Multi Pack _ Stone Ground Mustard

3-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F 170°F 180°F

Ringhand's Beer Mustard

Stonewall Kitchen - Horseradish Mustard

LocalFolks Foods Stoneground Xxpress Mustard 8oz.

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 160°F/71°C

Pope Poupon

Georgia's Northside Smoked Jalapeno

Maple Mustard

Dishwasher Rinse Temp THERMOLABEL® 180°F/82°C

Terrapin Ridge Smokey Maple Bacon Mustard

Smoked Cheese Bites

5-Temp THERMOLABEL® Classic 140-180°F

Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Honey Mustard

Bourbon Molasses Mustard

Stonewall Kitchen Bourbon Molasses Mustard

Garlic Mustard

Hot and Sweet

Garlic Mustard

MUG-O-MUSTARD 16 oz

1-Temp THERMOLABEL® 165°F/73.9°C

Stadium Mustard

Galloway Whole Grain Mustard

Pure NH Maple Sugar Resealable Bag

Maple Mustard

Spicy Honey Mustard

10 oz. Pub Mustard

Maple Kettle Corn

Redstone Creek Harissa Mustard

Jilly's Dilly Mustard

Simply Red Ale Mustard

Big Pete's BBQ Sauce

Mustard - Powder

Horseradish Mustard

Spicy Honey Mustard

Doughnuts- (Boxes of 6) WEEKENDS ONLY

Truffle Mustard

Traditional Pub Style Mustard

Stonewall Kitchen Mustard

Skim Milk

Sierra Nevada Stout & Stone Ground Mustard

Reviews

Delivery & Returns

blackwatermustardco.com

You might also like

Everyday Cafe & Pub Mustard