Charmed Pumpkin Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

It's Christmas and We're all in Misery Gauge Ruler by Muster Pattern

$12.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Devil Shoe Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Elm Leaves Needle Stoppers

(3)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Witchy Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Wrath on Tortured Hero (Merino) Bulky

Rose Yarn Co.

Popsicle | Progress Keepers

$14.50

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Spooky Book Club Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Come See Inside My Bones on Opposites Attract (Merino Cotton) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog Outlier Batch on All Bases

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Aether on Morally Grey (MSY) DK

Knit and Living

Pumpkin stitch marker

$3.47

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Round Sweater Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Hands off my pumpkin! on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) DK

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Love Ghosty Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Crescent Moon Needle Stoppers

(3)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Morally Grey is my Favorite Color Needle Stoppers

(1)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Dinosaur Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Beer Needle Stoppers

AdoreKnit

Nothing Suspicious In These Woods Progress and Stitch Markers

$5.50

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Zodiac Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Helm's Deep on Tortured Hero (Merino) Bulky

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Daddy Logan on Morally Grey (MSY) Fingering

$40.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog on Smut (Tweed) DK

Craft House Magic

Enamel Front and Back progress keepers (set of 2)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Pie Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Snots on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Outlier on Forced Proximity (Suri) Lace

The Frosted Stitch

(136)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

I Never Drink Wine Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Dark Romance Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Lórien by Moonlight on Morally Grey (MSY) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

In My Era Needle Stoppers

(1)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Crystal Ball Needle Stoppers

Two capybara charms on a skein of blue yarn.

Toil & Trouble Yarns

Capybara Charm / Stitch Marker / Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Cat Mom Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog on One Bed (Merino Linen) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Alpaca Needle Stoppers

4% off

Polka Dot Creek Yarn

2026 Blanket Club!

(2)

$159.00$166.00

Craft House Magic

Holly stitch markers or progress keepers (set of 3)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Daddy Charlie on Morally Grey (MSY) DK

$40.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Hands off my pumpkin! on Dark Past (AMYS) Lace

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Fangtasia on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) DK

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Bookmark Needle Stopper Holder

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

The One Ring Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Andarna Ball Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Mischief Helmet Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Witch Eye & Moth Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Sassy Fall Needle Stoppers

Loops And Layers

Popsicle | Progress Keepers

$19.00

Explorer Knits + Fibers

(703)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Side of the Dark Helmet Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Outlier on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Algiers on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) DK

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Magical Herbs Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

River Crossing on Cat & Mouse (Cotton Merino) Worsted

$37.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Birch Bristles on Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Lady of Lórien on Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Books Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Sci-Fi Princess Progress Keeper

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Stitch Marker Sets

(1)

$4.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

My love for you will keep me alive, forever on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Snowflake Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Bat Needle Stoppers

55% off

AdoreKnit

Most Sincere Pumpkin Patch Progress and Stitch Markers

$4.48$9.99

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Christmas Vacation Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Daddy Aragorn on MINE. (AMS) DK

$37.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Daddy Aragorn on One Bed (Merino Linen) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

River Crossing on Touch Her and Die (NSW) Fingering

$35.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Cauldron Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Envy on Morally Grey (MSY) Lace

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Moonhunter on Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

My Only Hope on Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Balrog on Touch Her and Die (NSW) DK

Rose Yarn Co.

Colorful Cat | Progress Keepers

$14.50

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Bride of Frankenstein Needle Stoppers

$8.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Fangtasia on Morally Grey (MSY) DK

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Gimli on Tortured Hero (Merino) Bulky

Fia Fia

Sweet Heart Progress Keeper

$9.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Glow in the Dark Needle Stoppers

$4.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Alice in Wonderland Project Bag by Ginger Snap That

$41.00

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Greed on Forced Proximity (Suri) Lace

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

My love for you will keep me alive, forever on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) DK

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Baby Alien Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Witch Sisters Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Deep Sea Daddy OOPS on *Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering

(1)

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Crown Needle Stoppers

Fantasy Fibers Yarn Co.

Lórien by Moonlight on Enemies to Lovers (85/15) Fingering