Wendigo Plush Toy

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skelekitty Plush Toy [Purple Bones Limited Edition]

(30)

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Night Owl Skeleton Plush Toy

(1)

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Stitch Kitty Plush Toy

(3)

Mysterious

4.9

(24.4K)

Plushie Dreadfuls -Obsidian Kintsugi Love Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Animal - toy

Pumpkin Cream Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Animal - toy

Skulls Unlimited International, Inc.

Skelekitty Plush - Single

(1)

Exclusive deal available

CuddlyCryptids

Mythical Kelpie Plush with Poseable Bendable Tail

(5)

$38.99

Exclusive deal available

CuddlyCryptids

Chupacabra Stuffed Plush Toy

(2)

Monster Stuff Store

Fresno Nightcrawler Plush (~8")

$16.00

Exclusive deal available

Plushie Patch

Ghostface Horror Plush Toy – Scary Movie Stuffed Animal

$35.00

75% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Kreepy Kuties: Medusa Plush Toy

(11)

$5.00$20.00

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Bitter Cherry Plush Toy

(2)

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Kreepy Kuties Element Cats Aether

(2)

$12.50$25.00

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Baby Cthulhu Plush Toy

(43)

$29.99$31.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Grim Creeper Plush Toy

(12)

$24.99$31.99

Strike Gently

4.9

(47.5K)

Gold locking pin clasp, a replacement back for enamel pins

Assortment of Strike Gently vinyl stickers, including holographic designs, from the Mystery Sticker Pack

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

VF Sticker Pack

(162)

$4.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skeletoad Plush Toy

Exclusive deal available

CuddlyCryptids

Wendigo Pup Stuffed Plush Toy

(42)

Exclusive deal available

TOTYM

'Wendell' the Wendigo 🦌 | Plush

(20)

$35.00

Coco Village

Vampire Plush Toy

(2)

Exclusive deal available

Haunted

Black Cat Skeleton Splitzokitty Plush Toy Black and White Split

$33.00

Exclusive deal available

Tiny Teeth

Werewolf (Yellow Eyes) Cryptid Crush Plush

(17)

$55.00

Perished Plushies

Hemlock Jackalope Plushie

$35.00

Mattel Creations

4.9

(187.4K)

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Element Cats Aether

(4)

$27.50$55.00

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Kreepy Kuties Element Cats Fire

(5)

$12.50$25.00

Dolls Kill

4.5

(118.8K)

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Rainbow Skelekitty Plush Toy

(11)

$31.99

black embroidered goat skeleton stuffed animal plushie

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skelegoat Plush Toy

embroidered stuffed animal skeleton plushie with spiral tail

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skelepig Plush Toy

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Dead Inside Skeleton Gloves [Full Finger]

(67)

$8.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Heavy Metal Panda Plush Toy

(2)

$24.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Pumpkin Toad Plushie

$33.99

Exclusive deal available

Tiny Teeth

Werewolf (Red Eyes) Cryptid Crush Plush

(4)

$50.00

Sterye Mystery Boxes

4.8

(2.4K)

Sterye's Creepy Carnival poster featuring a creepy clown-like character standing in front of vintage circus tents and red curtains, with large marquee-style text reading 'STERYE'S CREEPY CARNIVAL'.

A dark gray krampus plush toy character with red button eyes, a white stitched mouth, brown and red striped horns, and a small brown bag with a candy cane, shown on a plain white background.

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Halloween Ghosts Wrapping Paper [30" X 196"]

(5)

$10.99

Mysterious

Dreadful Cryptid Rabbit - Plush Stuffed Cryptid Animal

(23)

$50.00

75% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Kreepy Kuties: Pumpkin Jack Plush Toy

(18)

$5.00$20.00

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Element Cats Fire

(5)

$27.50$55.00

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Grumpy Bones Bear Plush Toy

(54)

$37.99

Display-worthy building sets

Marble runs and rockets for ages 8-14.

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Nightcrawler Skeleton Spider Plush Toy

(1)

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skelekitty Plush Toy

(48)

Gothic woman holding a skeleton rat plushie

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Bubonic Rat Plush Toy

(1)

black and white embroidered skeleton snail slug bug insect plushie stuffed animal toy

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Slugula Skeleton Snail Plush Toy

10% off

The SCP Store

SCP 323 The Wendigo

(6)

$22.50$25.00

Exclusive deal available

Tiny Teeth

Scarred Werewolf Cryptid Crush Plush

(26)

$55.00

Exclusive deal available

CuddlyCryptids

Mothman Stuffed Plush Toy

(28)

$36.99

Boredwalk

4.9

(17.8K)

Purely Wicked Apothecary

Evil Vampire Plush 7.5"

$26.00

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Beet-Rot Plush Toy

(1)

70% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Gonk Plush Toy

(27)

$12.00$40.00

emo black and green stitched monster cat plush

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Frankenkitty Plush

(9)

$29.99$31.99

pink and white creepy cute kawaii skeleton cat stuffed animal with a hair bow

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Smitten Kitten Plush

(16)

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

X-Ray Skelekitty Plush Keychain

(6)

black and red spooky skeleton cat keyring plush

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Blood Skelekitty Plush Keychain

(5)

Dinosaur playsets

Puzzles, figures, and fossil dig kits.

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Moon Raccoon Plush Toy

(1)

Mothman, Bigfoot, Wendigo, Flatwoods Monster cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive deal available

Strange Fellows

The Whole Gang

(8)

$199.00

Exclusive deal available

CuddlyCryptids

ShadowThorn Beast Plush Toy

(7)

$45.99

Skulls Unlimited International, Inc.

Batty Bones Plush

(3)

Exclusive deal available

Logan's Toy Chest

Nightmare Critters Plush Toy – Cute & Creepy Horror Stuffed Animal

$15.97

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Vampear Plush Toy

(3)

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Sorrowberry Plush Toy

(2)

Spooky Cat Press

(5.6K)

Four Halloween die-cut vinyl stickers featuring retro monster designs laid out on a dark wood surface next to a wooden ruler for scale. The stickers look like vintage classic monster trading cards

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Poe's Raven Plush Toy

(19)

$24.99$31.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Mothman Plush Toy

(29)

$29.99$32.99

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Skelekitty Plush Keychain

(23)

embroidered hot pink and black skeleton kitty cat keychain for adults

Exclusive deal available

VampireFreaks

Bubblegum Skelekitty Plush Keychain

(2)

Bleak Boutique

Wendigo Folk Horror Cryptid Plush Toy

(5)

$24.95

Wendigo cryptid plushie from classic American folklore and cryptozoology

Exclusive deal available

Strange Fellows

Wendigo Plushie

(72)

$60.00

What's Up, Cupcake? Whimsical Crafts LLC

Cryptid Mystery Box

(1)

$20.00

Clay sculpting sets

Starter kits, clay packs, and tools.

Skulls Unlimited International, Inc.

RIP Rabbit Plush

Hanode Shop

Spooky Vampire Plushie

(8)

$30.00

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Aggrocado Plush Toy

(5)

50% off

KILLSTAR - US Store

Hexanana Plush Toy

(4)