Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Shelby's

Products

Products

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Toothpick Caddy Set, Assorted Styles

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$11.25

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shopping designed around you.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Quantity

1

Description

These cute 2-piece set features a hand-painted stoneware caddy that holds a pack of wooden toothpicks. Works perfect for serve boards and entertaining!

Delivery & Returns

Shelby's

5 (23)

You might also like

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430039x Outdoor Retreat Toothpick Caddy Set - 4 Styles

(1)

HighlandSide Interiors, Gifts and Monogramming

Christmas Toothpick Holder with Toothpicks

Aimaleigh's Boutique

Mudpie Toothpick Holder

The Rustic Market

Golf Toothpick Set

Fiesta Toothpick Caddy Set - Veranda Cafe & Mercantile

Veranda Cafe & Mercantile

Fiesta Toothpick Caddy Set

50% off

Hartz Honey Hole

Fall Toothpick Holder

(1)

Emma Lou's Boutique

MudPie Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets

A. Dodson's

Golf Cart Toothpick

A. Dodson's

Scattered Rackets Toothpick

Aimaleigh's Boutique

Gather Toothpicks

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Set - Assorted - Boutique Bella Bellatoothpick holder

Boutique Bella Bella

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Set - Assorted

Shelby's

Mud Pie| Burl Wood Lidded Canisters

High Cotton Downtown

Woven Salt, Pepper & Toothpick Caddy Set

Monarch Boutique

Blue Willow Toothpicks & Holder

Pretty N Bliss

Mud Pie White Christmas Toothpick

The Islander FMB

Mud Pie Shell Toothpick Caddy Set

shopflowersplus.com

MUD PIE HALLOWEEN TOOTHPICK HOLDER SET

Set of four decorative toothpick holders shaped like a turtle, crab, starfish, and shell on a white background.

20% off

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Sea Figural Toothpick Holders

40% off

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Fall Toothpick Holder Set

(1)

Tonya's Treasures Inc.

Shell Toothpick Caddy Sets

High Cotton Downtown

Golf Toothpicks

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430037x Flower Toothpick Caddy Set - 4 Styles

Living room glow up

Living room glow up

Chic lighting, side tables, and linen layers.

Beyond the Barn Boston

Halloween Toothpick Holder

Tin Roof Gift Shop

Topiary Toothpick Holder

The Ivy Cottage

Topiary Toothpick Holders

Shelby's

Mackenzie Childs | Check Whistling Tea Kettle, Assorted Patterns

Avenue of the Oaks

Hand Painted Toothpick Holder w/Ruffle Rim

HighlandSide Interiors, Gifts and Monogramming

Wine and Cheese toothpick holders

Tonya's Treasures Inc.

Sea Shell Toothpick Tray Set

oshang

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Tortoise Ice Bucket Set

High Cotton Downtown

FARM ANIMAL TOOTHPICK CADDY SETS

Eloise Trading Company

Golf Toothpick Holders

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie 26 40430042x Golf Toothpick Caddy Set - 3 Styles

50% off

HighlandSide Interiors, Gifts and Monogramming

Easter Toothpick Holder with Toothpicks

ImaginArte

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

(1)

Lit Decor and Gift

Easter Toothpick Caddy Set

shopflowersplus.com

MUD PIE THANKSGIVING TOOTHPICK CADDY

Lucy Rose

Topiary Toothpick Holder

Briarwood Gifts

Fall Toothpick Holders

Shelby's

Mud Pie| Dark Orange Pumpkin Salad Plate

Heartisans Marketplace

Toothpick Holder

LOCAL FIXTURE

WINE & CHEESE TOOTHPICK CADDY SETS

Shelby's

Christmas Figural Handle Mug, Assorted Styles

34% off

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets 2026

Shelby's

Grill Platter & Marker Set

Mud Pie Mud Pie Golf Toothpick Holder Set - 3 Styles | CeCe's Home & Gifts

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Golf Toothpick Holder Set - 3 Styles

Dining table, elevated

Dining table, elevated

Table lamps, serveware, and textured linens

RSVP Gifts and More

Ceramic Toothpick Holder

(1)

Farm Animal Toothpick Caddy Sets

Steve's Hallmark

Farm Animal Toothpick Caddy Sets

30% off

Stitching Around Collections

Christmas Toothpick Holders

Two Friends

Sea Shell Toothpick Holders - 4 Styles

Vine + Branch Florist

Easter Toothpick Caddy Set

Hot Pink Brentwood

Pink Base Flower Toothpick Holder

RiverWinn

Chinoiserie Toothpick Holders

The Wreath Stand

Flower Toothpick Caddy Set

(1)

Mud Pie Mud Pie Farm Christmas Toothpick Holders - 4 Styles | CeCe's Home & Gifts

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Farm Christmas Toothpick Holders - 4 Styles

(1)

Pick Ups Toothpick Holder

NRS

Mud Pie Pick Ups Toothpick Holder

Estelle Colored Glass

Estelle Colored Decanter- Heritage {Blush Pink}

(1)

The Merry Magnolia

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy

Smyth Jewelers

Mud Pie Tidbit & Toothpick Sets

The Rustic Market

Tailgate Toothpick Caddy Sets

Cute toothpick decoration for Thanksgiving

Annies Hallmark & Gretchens Hallmark

Mud Pie LLC: Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy Sets

Hot Pink Brentwood

Pink Flower Toothpick Holder

Shelby's

Mud Pie | Twisted Handle Mug

Toothpick Caddy Sets - Wine and Cheese

Madison's Niche

Toothpick Caddy

(1)

A. Dodson's

Shell Toothpick Holder

shopflowersplus.com

MUD PIE EASTER TOOTHPICK CADDY SETS

Craft Closet

Mudpie- Tailgate Toothpick Caddy Sets #40430047

Stitching Around Collections

Toothpick Holder

English cottage touches

English cottage touches

Collected classics with country-house charm

Mud Pie Mud Pie Christmas Toothpick Tray & Caddy Set - 2 Styles | CeCe's Home & Gifts

CeCe's Home & Gifts

Mud Pie Christmas Toothpick Tray & Caddy Set - 2 Styles

(3)

A Sign of Grace, LLC DBA: Mezoozah Boutique & Corner Sweets

Thanksgiving Toothpick Set

Mud Pie - Toothpick Holder - Golf - Findlay Rowe Designs

Findlay Rowe Designs

Mud Pie - Toothpick Holder - Golf

Shelby's

Mud Pie| White Pumpkin Salad Plate

Two Tulips Boutique

Mud Pie Tailgate Toothpick Caddy Sets

The Ivy Cottage

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

Wine and Cheese Toothpick Holder Mud Pie-Mud pie-The Bugs Ear

The Bugs Ear

Wine and Cheese Toothpick Holder Mud Pie

A. Dodson's

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

Lit Decor and Gift

Stoneware Flower Toothpick Set

Adelyne's Boutique & Gifts

Thanksgiving Toothpick Caddy

Monarch Boutique

Wine & Cheese Toothpick Caddy Sets

Estelle Colored Glass

Estelle Colored Decanter- Vogue {Rose}

(1)

Tonya's Treasures Inc.

Gather Toothpick Set

Shelby's

Aspen Mulling | Cider Spice Drink Mix, Assorted Flavors

Piper Lillies Gift Shoppe

Mud Pie MP 40430007xx Fall Toothpick Holder Sets

Citrus and Moss

Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets, 4 assorted (sold separately)

The Gingham Pig… a Meat Boutique!

Farm Toothpick Caddy

Eliza B's

Easter Toothpick Caddy Sets | Assorted Styles