Tall Long Sleeve A-List Crew

I purchased 3 of these shirts and each one fits differently than the others. There seems to be no consistency in sizing.

I have been buying A-List tees in both short and long sleeve for several years. I have convinced my brother in law to try them and he is now happily buying them. They are nearly perfect in my opinion. I would like a slightly narrower collar trim but it is a very minor issue for me.