Thru Line Waterproof Eyeliner

Doesn’t stay put

I had really high hopes for this, but unfortunately it doesn’t stay put for me. By the end of the day I have raccoon eyes. On the plus side, the color is rich and the pencil is soft enough that it has a decent glide. With that said, it’s soft enough it does t hold a point so I need to sharpen it after every use (meaning from from eye to the next) if I want to do any sort of precision.

Why have I not found this before now

If your 29 year old daughter say ‘your eye make up looks good’ A: you feel you’ve scored the winning World Cup goal. B: you know you’ve found your go to eyeliner. Stays on all day and doesn’t smudge. Perfect Thank you x

Too soft to sharpen

I love this product, but it went from ok to bad. I liked the eyeliner that you just rolled up to use, except it was so soft I lost half of it through breakage. The company kindly sent me the improved version for shipping costs and I like it less. The formula is great and goes on so smoothly and stays on, but this one you have to use a sharpener. I will not reorder.