Indulgent, rich, and unmistakably Lancaster, Shoofly Pie coffee captures the classic flavor of Pennsylvania Dutch tradition in every cup. This delicious blend features gooey molasses notes with warm vanilla, brown sugar, and a touch of baked crumb topping, creating a smooth, comforting brew inspired by the region’s most iconic dessert.
A
4.8
33 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Great flavor
This is one of the flavors we keep coming back to. Love it
K
Kaylee · September 19, 2026
very tasty
Very pleased with the shoofly pie coffee I have purchased. While brewing I love the aroma and also the non bitter taste. Highly recommend.
F
Fred · July 22, 2026
Shoofly Pie
My first sip, I was undecided if I would like this one. But the more I had, the flavor grew on me. Finished the bag this morning and is on my re-order list of flavors.