Four ingredients to rule them all: Peanut butter, caramel, chocolate, pretzels. Plus one not-so-secret ingredient — honey — which gives our peanut butter ice cream a dreamy, nougat-y texture and flavor. Think of eating this flavor like digg...
Reviews
4.6
295 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Best Ever ! !
Absolutely love the High Five Candy Bar. Have to have a scoop or two every day. The best!!
C
Carole · May 25, 2026
Recommend Jeni’s.
All of these flavors are highly recommended. Hard to rank as all are number 1.
D
Debbie · May 6, 2026
My favs. . . High Five Candy Bar and Savannah Buttermint
High Five Candy Bar. . . . reordered this one along with Savannah Buttermint. Absolutely delicious. . . just the right amount of candy and chocolate. Can't wait for my next shipment this week.
