Jeni has never been a fan of mint ice creams. But when she opened Jeni’s in 2002, she wanted to offer something to the mint-loving crowd. Her challenge: Create a mint ice cream that even she could love. Savannah Buttermint—inspired by those melt-in-your-mouth, pillow mint candies in the restaurants of our grandparents’ generation—was the
4.7
185 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Favorite flavor!
Really good! But you cannot buy in any retail stores, you have to get from Jenis directly. Not only for more money per pint but it,s hard to ship! Jenis was great with replacing it, however.
N
nancy · September 16, 2026
Buttermint
Yum nothing overly special tho
D
Dillon · October 20, 2026
Love Buttermint candy but . . .
Hmmm, I love anything with mint!! Butter mint candy is a favorite, so I expected the smooth flavor of mint in the cream. I was not expecting the white chocolate pieces, and I found them to be a distraction; they added nothing in terms of flavor, and were waxy. Had there been a way to incorporate butter mint pieces, that would’ve been a pleasant experience.