Easily the most unforgettable ice creams Jeni has ever created. Nothing flies out of our freezer faster than these five tried-and-true best-sellers.
Heads up: we’re in the process of updating our packaging. The artwork on the pint you receiv...
Reviews
4.6
262 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
I love my mom and my mom loves this ice cream
I sent my mom the Best Sellers Collection for Mother's Day, and she was SO happy. She's quite picky about ice cream and usually think it's too sweet or not sweet enough, or too thick or not creamy enough, or needs "something. " But she only had gushing things to say about every flavor in this combo! My dad was also happy because my mom was happy, and because she usually doesn't buy ice cream. Thanks Jeni's for a hugely successful Mother's Day gift!
D
David · May 19, 2026
Recipient loved the flavor variety.
T
Terry · 6 days ago
Awesomeness
I have sent these 5 pack to friends for years. At least 20 times and have nothing but glowing reviews. My friends have also sent the 5 pack to their friends Bottom line is the ice cream is amazing After all the gifts i think I need to send a 5 pack to myself
