Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Got 3 uses out of the eyeliner and one of the lip pens, don't even want to waste time on the other lip pen, they are like dried out and nothing comes out. Disappointed

Foam tip gets dry at the end. Hard to do sharp lines with it, but once the eyeliner is on it wears like iron.

It looks more like black than I was hoping, possibly because I'm so pale in complexion. But the formula is smudgeproof and I like the applicator tip.