Optimist Botanicals are brought to you from California, its portfolio of spirits inspired by the state's natural treasures. SMOKEY was inspired by trips out of LA to the High Desert, reminiscent of crackling fires after the sun sets across ...
Reviews
3.0
6 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
Pleasant as its own spirit but not as a mezcal replacement
Optimist's Smokey is a pleasant non-alcoholic, botanical spirit with a gentle smoke profile, but tastes nothing like a mezcal as it is advertised. The taste is much more floral and the body much lighter than a genuine maguey mezcal. It is generally unremarkable as a sipping drink and does not accurately replace mezcal in typical cocktails like a mezcalita or a paloma. I have not tried this yet, but think it would work well in a negroni-like cocktail due to the floral character that is somewhat gin-adjacent.
S
Sean · January 8, 2026
Smokey and packs a punch
I’m a long time mezcal enjoyer, but have been trying to cut back on my alcohol consumption. On its own, this just tastes like lightly Smokey water, but when used in a well balanced cocktail — wow!!! So nuanced. I now like it better than actual mezcal, because I find the flavor to be more complex. I really like that it both is herby/botanical and Smokey. I would recommend this to anyone who likes both gin and mezcal.
J
Jessy · March 6, 2024
Smokey is phenomenal!
Now my go to in a great NA cocktail, especially in a Mule or Marg