Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

Baxter's Game Store

Products

Products

Baxter's Game Store

Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2016]

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$1.00

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shopping designed around you.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Quantity

1

Description

Set: Welcome Deck 2016 Type: Creature — Nightmare Horse Rarity: Rare Cost: {5}{B} ...

Delivery & Returns

Baxter's Game Store

4.9 (387)

You might also like

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [Welcome Deck 2017] [Non-Foil]

Baxter's Game Store

Valgavoth's Onslaught [Duskmourn: House of Horror]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [276] [Magic 2015] [Non-Foil]

Grey Ogre Games

Nightmare [Fourth Edition]

Alara Games AB

Nightmare [Magic 2015]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (4ED)

(1)

King's Table Games

5

(38)

Baxter's Game Store

Stormfront Riders [Planar Chaos]

Game Grid - Lehi Store

Nightmare [Magic 2014]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [146] [Classic Sixth Edition] [Non-Foil]

Crested Sunmare

Iron Knight Gaming

Crested Sunmare [HOU - 6]

Baxter's Game Store

Devilthorn Fox [Shadows over Innistrad]

The Stadium Frankenmuth

Nightmare Shepherd [Theros Beyond Death]

House of Cards

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Chimera Gaming

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

(1)

Enter The Battlefield

Nightmare [Ninth Edition]

Baxter's Game Store

March of the Multitudes [Starter Commander Decks]

Mothership Books and Games - Austin

Nightmare [Revised Edition]

Hinokami Collectibles

Hinokami Collectibles

5

(60)

One MTG

Nightmare [Fourth Edition]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [150] [Seventh Edition] [Non-Foil]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [164] [Tenth Edition] [Non-Foil]

House of Cards

Nightmare [Magic 2014]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [119] [Collectors Edition] [Non-Foil]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (Foil) (M10)

Atlantis Games & Comics

Wandermare (ELD-U)

Baxter's Game Store

Darkness [Legends]

The Game Corner

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Victory Point Games LLC

Victory Point Games LLC

5

(244)

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Vine Mare (M19)

Poke Hideout

5

(25)

Baxter's Game Store

Cruel Revival [Starter Commander Decks]

Tabletop Gaming Center

Nightmare [Revised Edition]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [W17-17] [The List] [Non-Foil]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (5ED)

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [107] [Magic 2010] [Non-Foil]

Baxter's Game Store

Horror Token [Gatecrash Tokens]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (9ED)

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [150] [Ninth Edition] [Non-Foil]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Crested Sunmare (HOU)

(1)

The Colosseum

5

(4.1K)

Face to Face Games

Recurring Nightmare [bs72] [World Championship Decks 1998] [Non-Foil]

Face to Face Games

Crested Sunmare [6] [Hour of Devastation] [Foil]

(2)

Game Grid - Lehi Store

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Tier 1 Games

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

House of Cards

Nightmare [Revised Edition]

PegasusBrz

PegasusBrz

5

(111)

Guardian Games LLC

Nightmare [Revised Edition]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (10E)

Tabletop Gaming Center

Nightmare [Magic 2010]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (3ED)

Baxter's Game Store

Gloomlake Verge [Duskmourn: House of Horror]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [184] [Fifth Edition] [Non-Foil]

Tabletop Gaming Center

Nightmare [Ninth Edition]

401 Games

Nightmare Shepherd (DSC)

(3)

Game Grid - Lehi Store

Carnival Hellsteed [Return to Ravnica]

Fabricator's Forge

Fabricator's Forge

5

(2.4K)

Palworld TCG: Dawn of Palpagos Booster Display

Palworld TCG: Dawn of Palpagos Booster Display

Pokemon 30th Celebration Elite Trainer Box

Riftbound Vendetta (Set 4) Booster Display

Tabletop Gaming Center

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

(1)

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Plague Mare (M19)

(1)

Dread Presence

Boutique Awesome

Dread Presence

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [150] [Fourth Edition] [Non-Foil]

Baxter's Game Store

Fear of Infinity [Duskmourn: House of Horror]

Game Grid - Lehi Store

Nightmare [The List]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [150x] [Seventh Edition] [Foil]

Grey Ogre Games

Nightmare [Magic 2014]

Tako Games & Collectibles

5

(222)

Baxter's Game Store

Shipwreck Marsh [Innistrad: Midnight Hunt]

Chimera Gaming

Nightmare [Magic 2014]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [150] [Eighth Edition] [Non-Foil]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (ORI)

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare Shepherd (THB)

The Warp Gate

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Recurring Nightmare (EXO)

GalaxyOfGames

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [108] [Magic 2014] [Non-Foil]

Baxter's Game Store

Valgavoth's Onslaught (Showcase) [Duskmourn: House of Horror]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (M14)

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [282] [Magic Origins] [Non-Foil]

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (M10)

Canada's Source for MTG Cards and Magic The Gathering Sealed!

401 Games

Nightmare (7ED)

Baxter's Game Store

Glimmerburst [Duskmourn: House of Horror]

Face to Face Games

Nightmare [120] [Revised Edition] [Non-Foil]

Dragon Forge Games

Dragon Forge Games

5

(97)

Tabletop Gaming Center

Carnival Hellsteed [Return to Ravnica]

Most Excellent Gaming

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]

Crested Sunmare 6/199 (Hour of Devastation)

Good Games Morley

Crested Sunmare 6/199 (Hour of Devastation)

Nightmare Shepherd|12|0|0.00

Journey’s End Games

Nightmare Shepherd (Theros Beyond Death) Near Mint

Level Up Games MD

Crested Sunmare [Hour of Devastation]