Liquid Eyeliner

This one works for me

I have a hard time wearing pencil or gel liner as they always smear to places they shouldn't no matter what so I stick to liquid liners and those seem to do well. I wanted to try something less toxic so I got this and it has been wonderful. It stays put pretty much all day with some fading but no smudging. The container lasts me a long time as well. I'm still using the brown shade I got a couple years ago and I wear it several times a week. I hope that color comes back in stock as it is better for daytime wear but the black is very nice and rich. These don't itch or burn my eyes either.

Love the formula

I love this product. It doesn’t smudge. The only problem is the liner is so thin, it’s hard to draw a line. I wish the brush was slightly sturdier.

Not the same

Formula has changed and doesn’t apply the same