5-Year Aged Wisconsin Cheddar
Our 5-Year Aged Cheddar has a firm texture, a sharp, clean tanginess, and creamy sweetness on the finish. Cheddar gets most of its sharpness between three and five years. What Happens When Cheddar Ages?
As Ch...
Reviews
5.0
24 ratings
5
4
3
2
1
First, I've love shopping at Brennan's for decades! I placed 4 online orders for work associates. I looked at 3 similar companies before looking here. Brennan's ordering process was the only one that was robust enough to allow me to ship to 4 different people/addresses. Only a couple of days and they all had their professionally packed custom gift box. Brennans will absolutely be my "go to" in the future.
G
Ginger · January 11, 2026
Speedy & Delicious!
Received our order of 12 blocks of cheese 2 days after placing order! To SOUTH FLORIDA!! So nummy. We can't get that kind of cheese down here! Thank you
M
MATT · December 18, 2025
Easy ordering of fantastic cheeses with prompt shipping.