Home

Explore

View Cart

Deals

Saved

Suggested searches

Plant-based protein powders
Vegan leather handbags
Bedroom decor
Waterproof jackets
Hoodies

Learn more about how we use your data to personalize your experience and ads. Recommendations are for informational purposes only.

T

TheMysteryShack

Products

Products

TheMysteryShack

Pony Head Keychain

4.5 (1,234)

Sold 100+ last 30 days

20% off first order

$4.99

Color

Black

Quantity

Product description loading

Product description loading

This is the product description text that will appear here.

Shop is the next step on our mission to make commerce better for everyone.

Start selling

For brands

For creators

Build your store

Information

Shop Pay

Help center

Social

X (Twitter)

Instagram

Legal

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Your Privacy Choices

Powered by

|

Start selling for free

Language

© Shopify Inc. 2026

Quantity

1

Description

Pony Head's been shrunk and turned into a rubber keychain! She's still better than that Earth Turd, mmkay?
THIS IS A LIMITED RUN PRODUCT AND WILL NOT BE RESTOCKED WHEN SOLD OUT

Delivery & Returns

Returns accepted within 14 days

TheMysteryShack

TheMysteryShack

4.9 (3.3K)

More from TheMysteryShack

Dipper Keychain

(8)

Star vs. The Forces of Evil Lanyard

(5)

Tokoyami Keychain

(2)

Star’s Dimensional Scissors

(8)

Mabel Keychain

(3)

Bumper Stickers - Gravity Falls

(36)

Bill Cipher Plush

(99)

Hazbin Hotel Single Trading Cards - 2nd Edition

(139)

King Plush - Multiple Styles

(42)

The Owl House Posters

(118)

The Owl House - Mini PVC Figures

(33)

Grunkle Stan & Ford Plush

(81)

Related to TheMysteryShack

Sanshee

4.9

(12.8K)

Rain World - No Significant Harassment Iterator Plush

Five Nights at Freddy's - Golden Freddy Plush

(547)

Rain World - Gourmand Slugpup Plush

(294)

Five Nights at Freddy's - Freddy Plush

(438)

Stardew Valley - Blue Chicken Pillow Plush

(261)

Rain World - Inv Slugpup Plush

(309)

Rain World - Artificer Slugpup Plush

(259)

Five Nights At Freddy's Bonnie Collector's Plush Front Photo

Five Nights at Freddy's - Bonnie Collector's Plush

(821)

Rain World - No Significant Harassment Collector’s Pin

Rain World - The Watcher Slugpup Plush

(115)

Rain World - Hunter Slugpup Plush

(251)

Stardew Valley - White Chicken Pillow Plush

(193)

Toy Temple

4.9

(2.5K)

Funko POP! Gus Fring Breaking Bad #1936 [Toy Temple Exclusive] (PRE-ORDER)

Funko POP! Breaking Bad Set of 5 [Toy Temple Exclusive] (PRE-ORDER)

Steal a Brain Rot Roblox Official Blind Bag Figure w/ DLC Code Unreleased

(11)

Funko POP! Kratos (with Blades) God of War Ragnarok #1285 [Toy Temple Exclusive]

(9)

Funko POP! Breaking Bad Set of 2 [Toy Temple Exclusive] (PRE-ORDER)

Thrilljoy PIX! John Wick Chapter 4 LE 6000 [Toy Temple Exclusive] (Chance at Chase)

(23)

Funko POP! Castiel Supernatural #1840 [GITD] [Funko Exclusive] [Toy Temple]

(2)

Funko POP! Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle Set of 7 [GITD] (PRE-ORDER)

Funko POP! Astarion (Vampire Ascendant) Baldur's Gate #1245 [Toy Temple Exclusive]

(4)

Funko POP! Walter White Breaking Bad #1937 [Funko Exclusive] (PRE-ORDER)

Funko POP! Premium Zenitsu Agatsuma Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle #2502 [Common and Chase Bundle] (PRE-ORDER)

Funko POP! Lightning McQueen Cars #1708 [Toy Temple Exclusive]

(61)

Poppy Playtime Official Store

4.7

(6K)

yarnaby plush walking forward with mouth open

Yarnaby Deluxe 18" Posable Plush

(2.1K)

Player Avatar Plush

(338)

monster catnap plush facing at angle.

Monster CatNap Plush

(1.2K)

CatNap Plush

(3K)

smiling kissy missy poppy playtime 14" plush front

19" Kissy Missy Plush

(266)

Boxy Boo Plush

(470)

scary huggy wuggy poppy playtime 47" plush front

Jumbo 47" Scary Huggy Wuggy Plush

(210)

craftycorn plush standing

40% off

CraftyCorn Plush

(353)

DogDay Plush

(1.6K)

bobby bearhug plush standing facing forward

40% off

Bobby BearHug Plush

(391)

42 inches pj pugapillar plush facing front.

Jumbo 42" PJ Pugapillar Plush

(255)

doey the doughman plush from front

Doey The Doughman Deluxe 14" Posable Plush

(462)

CultureFly

Exclusive offer available

Dandy's World - Shelly 12" Plush

(90)

Set of colorful plush keychains on a white background

Dandy's World - Dandy and Mains Specialty Mystery Bag Clips

(27)

ghostface huggers full set

Ghostface - Huggers Decorative Mini Figures

(7)

Plush toy resembling a strawberry with a happy expression on a white background

Dandy's World - Sprout 12" Plush

(129)

Ghostface - Meltz Collectible Mystery Figures

(10)

Purple plush toy with a crescent moon on a white background

Poppy Playtime - 12" CatNap Plush

(2)

Gray plush backpack with a large eyes on a white background

Dandy's World - Pebble Plush Mini Backpack

(22)

Blue plush toy with large ears on a white background

Poppy Playtime - 12" Bubba Bubbaphant Plush

(1)

Ghostface - Ghostfaces In Different Places Artist Mystery Mini Vinyl Figures

(11)

mini 7 inch smiling critters plush bubba bubbaphant

Poppy Playtime Bubba Bubbaphant 7" Mini Plush

Set of colorful toy figures on a white background

Stranger Things - Meltz Collectible Mystery Figures

(1)

mini 7 inch smiling critters plush bobby bearhug

Poppy Playtime Bobby BearHug 7" Mini Plush

Discover top brands

Little Sleepies

Exclusive offer available

Little Sleepies

4.9 (407.1K)

Exclusive offer available

The GLD Shop

4.7 (173.9K)

Aviator Nation

Exclusive offer available

Aviator Nation

4.5 (94.4K)

32 Degrees

4.7 (228.2K)

Rockstar Original

Rockstar Original

Rockstar Original

4.7 (189.3K)

Fashion Nova

4.3 (428.8K)

Mandala Scrubs

Exclusive offer available

Mandala Scrubs

4.6 (11.9K)

Revice

4.4 (9.4K)

Culture Kings US

Culture Kings US

Culture Kings US

4.7 (151.5K)

OOFOS

Exclusive offer available

OOFOS

4.5 (179.8K)