Scallop Sconce, Black Sky

I bought two black sky color for a kitchen backsplash and they are a completely different finish. One is matte and the other is shiny. The back wiring also looks different and the clicker below. They are not a match. I expect much more consistency in quality and product description from a brand this expensive and considered so high end.

I expected matte finish and they are shiny :-( not in description. Maybe return them for unlacqured brass? Kim