Earth Eye Coal

Really wanted to love it. . .

this product did not meet my makeup needs. I was hoping to use it as a replacement for the cheap plastic smudgeable eyeliner I get from the drugstore for my edgier looks. unfortunately, the pigment was very difficult to use. none of my makeup brushes would pick it up, and i was barely able to get any when I tried with my finger. The product once applied was not pigmented at all, and it kinda just ended up making me look like I had sickly dark circles instead of looking like I was wearing brown makeup. I was really wanting this to work and am willing to give any future reformulations a try, but I will not purchase the as-is product again. Also, I received a free sample with my order that contained an ingredient that irritates my skin, so I couldn't use it. I cleaned & kept the little container it was in, but it still felt wasteful to scoop it all in the trash. It would be nice if there was a spot in our accounts we could put FATM ingredients that we can't use so that doesn't happen in the future.

I love this product. And here is another way to use it…I put a little of the earth shade on my lips just to give it a little color. So much better than lipstick!

Perfect. Easy to use and simple to apply. Great for all genders.