Hyperkin Xbox 20th Anniversary Duke Controller

would be perfect (forgiving no wireless) if you could keep the original xbox logo in the middle, but you can only make it appear for a second at the end of the splash animation, which itself is an absolutely awesome feature

Feels cheap, should be wireless at this price point, no rumble feature

I returned this because a trigger didn't zero out when released, but I assume they don't all do that and I'm not holding that against this review. Obviously I love the form factor, which is why I got it. But I was disappointed that it felt too much like the original in the actions, even worse. I was hoping for modern feeling triggers, buttons and sticks, but it felt cheap. The right stick grinds as you circle around, the controller equivalent of nails on a chalkboard. The bumper buttons are not well placed. The oled screen is not centered in the big button. This is priced above a Microsoft controller but Microsoft QC would not let this out the door.