Almost Perfect
Even though I grew up with the N64 and PSX back during their heyday, I must confess that I've personally never been a huge fan of the original N64 controller's ergonomics whenever I sat down to actually play my old N64 with said controller. For me, I think the biggest issues with the original controller was the slot on the back for a vibration pak or controller pak, as well as the relatively short side handles, ended up making the controller feel cramped for me whenever I held it using one hand to hold the center prong and my right hand to hold the right side of the controller. It just wasn't the most comfortable setup in a lot of cases, and the problem only grew worse as I grew older and my hands got bigger with age. That's why, ultimately, I'd go with a third-party alternative with different ergonomics whenever I could on either the N64 itself, or on any other hardware I could play my N64 library on.
But here and now, ModRetro's M64 Controller Pro Controller has truly impressed me (I own one purple controller, and one smoke controller). The changes they made to the original trident design of the N64 standard controller are relatively simple. They elongated all three handle bars by a small amount, and redesigned the back slot to accept different types of battery packs that keep the entire back of the controller nice and flush. Yet these simple changes have managed to practically eliminate the issues I had with the original trident design. They even use a TMR Gamecube-style analog stick and gate out of the box, and give you additional stick gates if you want to use something different, with one of them more closely resembling the stick gate you'd find on an original N64 controller. Coupled with the premium materials that's been used in its construction, the M64 Pro Controller is THE most comfortable and premium-feeling trident-style N64 controller that I've ever used, whether it be third party or Nintendo's own hardware.
Additionally, ModRetro, as of this writing, is going to eventually open up a parts shop that will sell you replacement/custom parts which you can use to swap out the button membranes to give you different levels of resistance/feedback, faceplates if you want to swap to different colors, etc., and the design of the controller makes it easy to open it up and swap out whatever you want, giving owners the option to customize their controller exactly to their liking, and give you the means to repair/replace broken sticks and membranes, with relatively little hassle compared to other third party alternatives.
However, even with all these praises, I DO unfortunately have one point of contention with the controller's design. The redesigned slot on the back of the controller will make it difficult to use for certain titles on other hardware that isn't the M64, since there's no way to attach any kind of controller pak onto the controller itself, which will force owners to seek workarounds depending on what specific setup they're using that's not the M64. This won't be an issue with software emulators, but original N64 hardware and FPGA hardware that ISN'T the M64 (such as a MiSTer, or the Analogue 3D, to give a couple examples off the top of my head) is where the potential headaches can arise depending on what game you're trying to play. As a result, this limits the M64 Pro Controller's full functionality to specific hardware/software environments that were either designed for it, or can implement workarounds around the controller's lack of a pak slot. This might be a potential deal breaker for some, but fortunately in my case I think I can live with them just fine and use other controllers for different setups as needed. But even so, I'll admit that this design limitation keeps me from giving this controller a full 5-star rating.
All in all, the M64 Pro Controller, to me, is almost perfect as far as a trident-style N64 controller goes. I gotta congratulate ModRetro for designing a version of the trident-style controller that has basically won me over by eliminating all the issues I had with the original N64 controller's ergonomics. Anytime I ever want to use a trident-style layout, this controller will now be my go-to option!